Reseller Says Old Pier 1 Pieces Are Selling On Ebay For Nearly $200 All The Way Up To $600, Including A Hard To Find Coastal Wreath That Brought $189 And A Set Of Ornaments That Sold For $235

·

·

When a big retail chain closes its stores, its old merchandise does not just vanish. Sometimes it turns into a treasure hunt, and a full-time reseller who goes by The Nurse Flipper says that is exactly what has happened with Pier 1.

Wooden shelves displaying vintage teapots, a radio and other old home decor pieces

She is Cat, working out of North Florida, and in a research video she walked through 20 Pier 1 sales from the past 90 days on eBay. The prices run from just under $200 to $600, and she admits some of them surprised her.

Why Closed Stores Made Pier 1 Pieces Worth Chasing

Cat says Pier 1 stores no longer exist in person, and she believes that has pushed up the value of the brand’s old items. She has sold plenty of it over the years, and she tells viewers to start looking for it if they are not already.

Her advice is simple. Almost all Pier 1 items carry a tag or a sticker, and when they do not, a phone app like Google Lens can often identify them. At an estate sale, she says, it is also worth just asking where something came from.

A Rare Coastal Wreath Brought $189

The first sale she shows is a Pier 1 coastal shell and seashell wreath listed as hard to find. It sold for $189.

She says she might even pay that price herself. Even without the name, she believes a really nice coastal wreath would probably bring more than $150.

A second wreath followed later, an Enchanted Circus Halloween wreath that sold for $245. Her takeaway is that high quality wreaths bring good money, and Pier 1 ones are worth watching for.

Four Curtain Panels Sold For $225, And She Says They Are Easy To Find Cheap

Linens are her specialty, so the curtains caught her eye fast. A set of four panels in a floral blue meadow pattern was listed at $225 and sold on a best offer.

A set of four woven floral panels, lined, also sold on a best offer around $225, and a set of four paisley panels sold for $250 with no offer needed. She says the paisley was bright and vibrant, and that quality is easy to feel in the fabric before you even look for the tag.

Here is the twist. Most Pier 1 linens she has come across at thrift stores cost only a few dollars, and she says Pier 1 is not a brand people tend to mark up. If you do have to pay more, she suggests looking up the pattern first, because popularity changes the price.

Twig Flatware, Snowflake Plates And Crackle Glasses Brought Serious Money

Dinnerware was another bright spot. A 25 piece set of Pier 1 Twig Branch Arbor gold stainless flatware sold for $225, which she points out is almost $10 a piece.

A set of nine embossed snowflake stoneware plates, clearly marked on the back, sold on a best offer, with the listing at $200. A set of teal blue crackle wine glasses, likely used at a wedding, sold for $318.

Cat shares her own best Pier 1 story here. She bought charger plates at an estate sale from people who had used them once for a wedding and said they came from Pier 1. She paid less than a dollar each and sold more than a hundred of them for $15 apiece.

A Witch Hat Tree And Halloween Ornament Lots Pulled In $220 To $260

She did not expect ornaments to dominate the list, and she says a good majority turned out to be lots of ornaments. A 24 inch glass witch hat tree with witch themed ornaments sold on a best offer, with the listing at $220.

A lot of Halloween ornaments with bats, jack-o’-lanterns and spiders sold for $235. Another lot mixing Halloween, Fourth of July and other ornaments sold for $260.

Then came the two biggest ornament sales. One lot sold for $549.99, and a lot of patriotic ornaments from the same seller sold on a best offer, with the listing at $600, the top of the list.

She says she did not see Pier 1 tags on many of those. A single set of trains from the lot, she estimates, could still bring around $100 to $150.

Old CD Racks, Wicker And Statues Were The Big Surprise

The item she says she never would have guessed is a pair of vintage Pier 1 CD and DVD bookcases. Made in September 2002, they sold for $375, which she calls incredible for something she would have written off as obsolete.

A Pier 1 Jamaica Collection white wicker nightstand with two drawers sold for $285. She says generic wicker nightstands turn up at thrift stores for $10 to $20 and sell for $200 to $300. Furniture is awkward to pack, she admits, but she says it is not fragile and ships fine with bubble wrap and a big enough box.

A pair of Brutalist abstract statues, a man standing 39 inches and a woman at 34 inches, sold for $290. She says the sellers paid $60 and $50 for them originally, so most of this Pier 1 stuff goes for far more than its original retail price. A Pot of Gold Lucky Leprechaun described as very rare brought $331, and she says she would have scrolled right past it.

Tips For Selling Or Hunting Pier 1 Pieces

Cat has a few rules of thumb. Show everything in one photo when you sell a lot, because buyers want to see exactly what they are getting. Show the tags, because they prove the brand.

Research what an item actually sells for instead of anchoring on the original price. She points to a set of fall dinner plates that were originally $11 each as proof that retail tags do not set the value.

It is also smart to turn furniture around and open the drawers, since higher end makers sometimes put their names inside.

Cat says she also sold a Pier 1 jewelry box for almost $300 in under a month. Her closing advice is to watch for the name at garage sales, estate sales and thrift stores. The next time you see a Pier 1 sticker, look twice before you walk by.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *