Antiques Roadshow Appraiser Known As The Black Widow Gambled On 52 Pieces Of An Old Building Covered In Tiffany Glass, Then Admitted She Might Be A Compulsive Gambler

·

·

When Antiques Roadshow staffers name the best poker players on the road, one nickname comes up first: the Black Widow. It belongs to appraiser Arlie Sulka, a Tiffany Studios expert and owner of the New York gallery Lillian Nassau LLC.

A vintage Tiffany-style stained glass lamp, matching an appraiser's gamble on 52 Tiffany glass pieces.

Her colleagues say she is a shark who will take your money without ever looking nervous. Now she has made a bet far bigger than any hand of cards, and the Antiques Roadshow Detours episode “The Tiffany Gamble” follows it from start to finish.

Six Pieces Of A Detroit Building Rolled Into The Las Vegas Show

At an Antiques Roadshow stop in Las Vegas, the item that excited Sulka most was a piece of Tiffany architectural history from the Farwell Building in Detroit. The guest arrived with six large, heavy sections of concrete and plaster covered in thousands of tiny pieces of Tiffany glass, cut into shapes reminiscent of the famous mosaics of Ravenna, Italy.

The glass was not just one kind. Sulka noted opalescent, gold iridescent and even textured glass of the sort seen in some Tiffany lamps, which she called unusual for a mosaic installation. “These are pieces of building,” she said. They were not the usual vase placed on a turntable.

A Looted Landmark, A City Bankruptcy And A Surprise Auction

The Farwell Building opened in March of 1915, when Detroit was still on its way to becoming the Motor City. It was built by the estate of Jesse Farwell, a wealthy shipping and real estate figure, and Tiffany Studios decorated it with marble walls, brass elevator grills, glass chandeliers and mosaic tile domes. Tiffany even published an ad about the work.

As Detroit declined, so did the building. Looters and scrappers began picking it apart in the 1970s, and by 1984 it was closed. Detroit historian Dan Austin remembers walking in as a kid, when tiles from Tiffany Studios were scattered across the floor. “You’d scoop up a handful on your way out,” he says.

After Detroit filed for bankruptcy in 2013, the city, which had seized the building over unpaid taxes, asked developers for proposals to save it. Richard, a lifelong preservationist from Detroit, was part of the team selected, and they took possession in 2015, a century after it was built.

The building had been vacant for about 35 years. The chandeliers were stolen in the 1970s, and looters had pulled out chunks of the mosaic domes. In late 2015 an attorney warned Richard that some of that stolen property was about to be auctioned the next morning, and the sale was stopped.

“Don’t Throw These Pieces Away”

The three glass tile domes were in really bad shape, and Richard says restoring them as they stood was impossible. He told his staff not to discard the mosaics and asked them to cut out roughly two-foot-square sections, because bigger pieces would be too heavy to move.

The two stolen pieces headed for the 2016 auction had a low-end presale estimate of $7,500 each. Richard figured about $45,000 for the six pieces, and he would have been happy with that.

The Appraisal That Shocked The Guest

Sulka valued the pieces individually. She put two at $15,000 to $25,000, one at $15,000 to $20,000, and another at $30,000 to $40,000, and the total retail range came to $135,000 to $190,000. “Wow, that’s incredible,” Richard said.

Still, the builder in him stayed skeptical. “Is there anyone out there that would actually pay that? Who would buy this stuff?”

“Oh, By The Way, I Have 52 Of Them”

Antiques Roadshow has a rule that appraisers and guests do not buy or sell on set, so the business happened afterward. Richard contacted Sulka’s gallery to say he wanted to sell, and he casually mentioned he had 52 pieces in all.

Many of them were in various states of disrepair. Sulka says she was “sweating bullets” wondering how to get them from Detroit to New York and where to put them, but she made a deal to take the entire pile. “I figured, well, I will sell the best ones and then we’ll see what happens with the others.”

Sulka likes that the pieces turned up in Vegas. “This is kind of a gamble,” she says, and you have to be a risk taker in this business. When host Adam Monahan asked whether she might be a compulsive gambler, her answer was a plain “Yes. Just buying stuff.”

Eleven Pieces, A Prestigious Armory And A $75,000 Corner

Her plan was the Winter Show at the Park Avenue Armory in New York, held every January and considered the most important antiques show in the country. Sulka brought 11 Farwell pieces and hoped to sell them all.

She priced the most impressive, a corner piece, at $75,000, while a slab could be had for as little as $25,000. Her buyer guess was blunt. “I think it would be a rich person.” Possible buyers also included an architect or a museum. Her dream was to see the two cornice pieces sold together, mounted on a wall.

On the first day she had sold a pair of sconces and a Tiffany vase, and no building parts yet. People did take photos in front of the display. “You can’t believe how many people were standing in front,” she said.

Three Sold, And Dozens Still Waiting

A few weeks later, Sulka reported three Farwell pieces sold, one at the show and two afterward, with a buyer considering the central piece in its special frame. The on-site buyer was ready to write a check, but she says she had to bargain. “I’m an antiques dealer.”

She is happy with the sale prices, though she admits, “I have a long way to go.” With about 20 pieces in storage and the rest at her gallery, she is hopeful an institution or designer will use them, and she would love to see a section donated to the Detroit Institute of Arts. Austin agrees it would mean a lot to the city.

What Collectors Can Learn From The Black Widow

This story has some useful lessons for anyone holding an unusual treasure:

  • Keep the history. The Farwell pieces drew attention because their Detroit origin and Tiffany link were well documented.
  • Pieces from one source are valued one by one. Condition, the part of the dome and the detail of the pattern all changed the price.
  • Know the show rules. Antiques Roadshow appraisals are free of buying and selling, so contact a dealer separately if you want to sell.
  • Expect a slow sale for large items. Even a top expert needed a major show and weeks to move three pieces.

For now, a deck of Tiffany sits waiting for the right buyer, and the Black Widow is still playing her hand.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *