Midcentury modern furniture has been hot for years, and where there is heat, there are shortcuts. Browse any online marketplace or walk through a busy flea market and you will see tapered legs, sculpted chairs and sleek sideboards advertised as authentic Eames, genuine Danish or real Heywood-Wakefield. Some are exactly what they claim. Plenty are not. Modern reproductions, copies and look-alikes are sold every day, and some are described in a way that lets buyers assume they are getting the real thing.

That matters because the price gap between a true vintage piece and a copy can be huge. Pay original prices for a reproduction and you have just made an expensive mistake. The good news is that a few minutes of looking, in person or through photos, can tell you a great deal.

Know What You Are Looking For

First, understand the names. Eames refers to the designs of Charles and Ray Eames, whose chairs and other pieces are produced under license by well-known manufacturers. Danish modern describes a style of furniture associated with Denmark, with many pieces made by named makers and many others made simply in that style. Heywood-Wakefield was an American furniture company, famous for its midcentury lines of blonde and honey-toned wood furniture.

Notice the difference between three ideas that sellers sometimes blur together: an authentic vintage piece, a licensed modern production of an original design, and an unlicensed copy. A licensed new piece can be perfectly legitimate and still not be a vintage antique. And a piece merely in the style of a famous design is not the famous design at all. Words like inspired by, style or type are worth noticing in a listing.

Start With Labels, But Do Not Stop There

• Look for a maker’s mark. Check the underside of seats and tabletops, the backs of drawers, the inside of cabinets and the legs. Original pieces often carry a label, stamp, burn mark or metal tag.
• Be suspicious of a perfect label. A crisp, shiny new tag on a piece that looks decades old deserves a second look. Labels can be moved, copied or added.
• Be suspicious of no label. Many vintage pieces have lost their tags over the years, so a missing label does not prove a fake. It just means you have to judge the piece on its construction and ask more questions.
• Compare to references. Look at photographs of known authentic examples from museum collections, books or established dealers, and compare label style, placement and the way the piece is built.

Check How It Is Built

Construction tells the truth even when labels do not. Turn the piece over, open the drawers and look at how it was put together.

1. Materials. Is it solid wood, real veneer or a cheaper composite board? Cheap board with a printed wood-grain finish is a red flag on anything sold as high-end vintage.
2. Joinery. Look at how the corners and drawers are joined. Careful, sturdy joints suggest quality. Glue blobs, staples and sloppy fits suggest otherwise.
3. Weight and feel. Quality older pieces often feel solid. Very light furniture with a hollow sound can be a clue to lower-grade materials.
4. Hardware. Screws, pulls and brackets should look right for the piece and show consistent age. Shiny, new-looking hardware on an old-looking piece is worth questioning.
5. Wear patterns. Real age shows up where hands, elbows and feet touch the piece. Wear sprinkled evenly everywhere, or wear that shows up in odd places, can mean someone distressed it on purpose.
6. Finish. Original finishes age in a particular way. A flat, plastic-looking coating or a color that seems too uniform may point to a modern production or a heavy refinish.

Ask Smart Questions Before You Pay

Do not be shy. A trustworthy seller will not mind questions. Ask where the piece came from, whether it has been refinished or repaired, and whether any parts are replaced. Ask for clear, well-lit photos of the underside, the joints and any markings. If a seller will not send them, consider that your answer.

Research recent sold prices for similar pieces, not just asking prices, so you know what the real market looks like. And be wary of a deal that seems far below the going rate for an authentic piece. Sometimes a low price simply means the seller does not know what they have. More often, it means the piece is not what the listing says.

Get Backup When The Stakes Are High

For a pricey purchase, consider paying for an expert opinion before you commit. A reputable dealer who specializes in midcentury furniture, or the maker’s own customer service for modern licensed production pieces, may be able to help. Get the seller’s description in writing, and keep a record of the return policy. If a seller says something is authentic, ask them to put that statement on your receipt.

A copy is not a crime to own. Plenty of reproductions are handsome, comfortable and fairly priced when sold honestly as what they are. The goal is simple: pay vintage prices for vintage furniture, and pay copy prices for copies.

More Stories You May Like

• Ruined Mid Century Modern Dresser Gets Brought Back to Life in a Transformation That Shows What Furniture Is Worth Saving
• Antique Dealer Shows How a 200 Year Old Walnut Wardrobe Goes Together Without a Single Screw, and Furniture Lovers Cannot Stop Watching
• Seamstress Rips Apart A Thrifted Nightgown And Sews It Into A Retro 1970s Style Skirt And Top Set With An Oversized Collar And A Hand Sewn Hem