The dresser looks perfect. The nightstands match it, the bed frame has the same warm glow, and the seller swears the whole bedroom set has been together since the day it was made. You hand over the money and haul it home. A year later you pull open a drawer and notice the wood inside does not match the wood outside, or that the screws look suspiciously shiny. It turns out your matching set was matched by someone, just not the original maker.

This happens in the antiques world more often than many buyers realize. Furniture changes hands for decades, parts are lost, and pieces get repaired, swapped and combined. Sometimes that is done honestly and disclosed. Sometimes it is not, and buyers pay a premium for what they believe is an original set.

What Is a Marriage?

In the antiques trade, a “marriage” is a piece of furniture made by joining two or more parts that did not start out together. A classic example is a cabinet top set onto a base that came from a different piece, or a table with a top from one table and legs from another. The parts may be the same age and the same style, which is what makes the join hard to spot. They may still not be a single original piece.

A marriage is not automatically worthless. Some are honest, well-made and sold for what they are. The problem is paying the price of an original, untouched piece for something put together later.

Clues Hidden in the Hardware

Hardware is one of the easiest places to start. Drawer pulls, hinges, locks and the screws that hold them often tell the story.

• Look for extra holes. Small empty holes around a pull, or a ghost outline of a different shape, can mean the original hardware was replaced.
• Check the screws. Old handmade or early screws tend to be irregular, with slots that are slightly off center. Bright, uniform, factory-looking screws in an old piece can mean the hardware is newer than the furniture. Slots with fresh scratches and shiny edges also suggest recent work.
• Compare the pulls. If one pull has a different color, wear or style than the rest, it may have been replaced.
• Look at the wear. Original hardware tends to show wear that matches the wood around it. Shiny, untouched hardware on a worn drawer front is worth a question.

Replaced hardware is common and not always a red flag, since owners often swap pulls for practical reasons. It does mean that a piece described as completely original may not be.

Clues in the Drawers and Construction

Pull a drawer all the way out and take a good look. The inside often tells you more than the front does.

• Check the joinery. The corner joints should look consistent from drawer to drawer. Dovetails of different styles or sizes within the same piece suggest that parts came from different places.
• Look at the wood. The inside wood, the drawer sides and the back should match from drawer to drawer. Different woods or widely different colors are a hint.
• Check for consistent aging. The finish and the color of the wood should age at a similar rate across the whole piece. A top that is a different shade from the base, or a drawer that is much lighter than the rest, deserves attention.
• Look underneath and behind. The back and the underside are less likely to have been refinished. Look for tool marks, old stains, saw marks and signs of repairs.
• Check that things fit. A top that sits oddly on a base, drawers that wobble, or gaps that look uneven can mean parts did not start together.

What About Real Matching Sets?

Not every set is suspicious. Many makers sold matching bedroom, dining and living room sets, and plenty of them survive together. A real set tends to share the same style, wood, finish, hardware and construction details across every piece. The details line up in a way that is hard to fake. If the details differ from piece to piece, or the story you are told does not match what you see, trust what you see.

Protect Yourself Before You Buy

1. Take a flashlight and your time. Open everything, look underneath and check inside.
2. Ask direct questions. Ask whether anything has been replaced, refinished or repaired, and whether the set has always been together.
3. Get it in writing. A receipt that describes the piece, its age and its condition protects you if the description turns out to be wrong.
4. Ask about returns. A seller who stands behind the piece will often give you a chance to have it checked.
5. Get a second opinion. For a big purchase, an appraiser or an experienced dealer is worth the fee.

An honest dealer will not be offended by any of this. Asking questions is part of the hunt, and the best deals come from knowing exactly what you are buying. Check the screws, pull the drawers, and let the furniture tell you its real story before you pay for it.

More Stories You May Like

• Antique Dealer Shows How a 200 Year Old Walnut Wardrobe Goes Together Without a Single Screw, and Furniture Lovers Cannot Stop Watching
• Couple Buys the Contents of an Antique Store That Has Been Abandoned for Twenty Five Years
• Chunky Plastic Bracelets In A Thrift Store Bin Could Be Bakelite Worth Thousands And A Warm Water Smell Test Can Help You Tell