It was a Monday morning, a 50% off day, and the host of The Dumont Boys called it “our favorite day to thrift.” He dropped his partner Andrew at one store to hunt carts and raced across town for an 8:00 a.m. opening at another.

By the end of a rare weekday haul that ran from Monday through Thursday, the two had spent $811 and figured they would sell everything for $6,706.
A Slow Start Until A Media Cart Rolled Out With A $75 Lord Of The Rings Set
The first hour was rough. A remote still cost $75 after the half-off discount, and a Bose CD player got the same hard pass. All the host had to show for an hour of digging was a Ken doll.
Then, just as he was about to leave, a media cart came out. On it sat a Lord of the Rings Blu-ray set that, he says, has already sold for $75.
A $13 Corded Mouse In The Glass Case Turned Into A Quick Flip
At a Goodwill with no half-off sale that day, he spotted a corded mouse in the case priced at $13. It still earned a pickup, and it has already sold too.
A gold Panasonic home phone system with call block and talking caller ID came next. He says he would pay $10 for it, and comparable listings run about $125.
At the next Goodwill he found three sealed Norel bath powders at $5 each. He expected about $65 for the set, though they were listed at $90.
Sealed X-Files Seasons And Printer Ink Quietly Paid The Bills
Ink is not exciting, the host admits, but it pays the bills. He bought eight HP 952 XL cartridges at $4 apiece and listed the lot at $120.
In the media aisle he found five sealed seasons of The X-Files at $5 a piece. They have already sold for $110.
Andrew’s Cart Haul Included A $1 Quake Box And A Sealed Barry Sanders Set
Andrew’s share of the loot was just as odd. He pulled big-box computer games for a dollar each, including Quake and the original Civilization II, and says the sealed Civilization II should bring $90 to $100.
A sealed Apple keyboard, he says, should go for about $70. He also picked up a sealed football card set with a Barry Sanders rookie that he figures is worth $45 to $50 and climbing.
Then came the best surprise of the first leg. They bought an LG Ultra HD Blu-ray player that powered on and ejected but could not be fully tested without a remote. An $18 replacement remote later, they were in it for $26 total, and it sold for $200.
The Flea Market Keyboard And A Samsung Gadget That Sold For $183
The next morning was an open-air flea market, where video games ran $5 each. The host learned long ago to ask for a price before looking up comps. A Casio keyboard with its carrying case and manual worked when they got it home and he called it “an absolute banger.”
At a Savers just after opening, Andrew showed him a Samsung One Connect on his phone’s comps. They paid about $14 and it has already sold for $183.
The host also found sealed D&D handbooks inside a box he thought was a starter set. They have already sold for $55.
Eight Original He-Man Figures For $5 A Bag And A Madame Leota Crystal Ball
Bags of original Masters of the Universe figures cost $5 each, and the host came away with eight figures and their accessories. He expects at least $75 for the lot. His 10-year-old self would have played with them, he says, and his 46-year-old self flips them.
As they were checking out, Andrew spotted a Haunted Mansion Madame Leota crystal ball on a top shelf. They tested it, it worked, and the host says he was “legitimately terrified.”
A second LG Ultra HD Blu-ray player turned up at that same store for $11. It came with its remote, and like its older twin, it sold.
Wednesday Was Mostly Trash, Then Thursday At The Bins Brought A Sega Genesis Mini And A Whole Haul For $7.37
Wednesday was mostly trash, the host says, though a sealed set of Sakura poster color markers for a buck saved the stop. Later he bought a Disney Animators Collection for $15 and says he expects at least $60 even with the dusty box.
A Kelly doll at $3, with a box that looked like it was run over by a truck, should still fetch $35. A new Garmin Drive 60 rounded out the day.
Thursday at the bins belonged to Andrew, who found a Sega Genesis Mini. They paid $4, tested it, and expect more than $100. The host adds that they once found a Sega Master System at the same bins.
The whole bin haul cost exactly $7.37. He challenged viewers to guess the total before he revealed it.
A Pressure Tactic At An Estate Sale Sent Him Home Empty Handed
At a 9:00 a.m. estate sale, the host spotted a Canon PowerShot priced at $130 near the door. The rule was that anything on that table had to be paid for before leaving the table, and he did not like the pressure, so he walked away.
Another seller wanted $250 for a dusty television that he says had not left its shed since Bill Clinton was in office. He passed on that too, and he also passed on a Lost complete series from 2009, which came out before the last season aired.
He did buy a $4 thermostat, a robot toy for $3 and sealed Canon ink.
The Final Count Was $811 In, $6,706 Out, And A $67 Steel Curtain Figure
Two keyboards cost $17 combined and should sell for more than $300. A Dwight White Steel Curtain figure, missing its helmet, cost $67 and should go for close to $300.
Total spent: $811. Estimated sales: $6,706. The hosts give their estimated profit as $4,023, which is their own figure and not simply the sales estimate minus what they spent, so treat it as a rough target.
The host says there is plenty to list and they will need to sell some of it to make room for the next haul.
What Resellers Can Take From A Four-Day Run
The pattern is easy to copy. Check sold listings before you buy, not asking prices. The host and Andrew leaned on comps for nearly every pickup and passed on things that looked cool but had little resale value.
Look in the glass cases and on the media carts, where small, sealed items like the corded mouse and the X-Files seasons turned up. Test what you can, as they did with the keyboards and the Sega Genesis Mini.
Remember too that estimated sales are not cash in hand. Fees, shipping and slow sellers all take a bite, so treat any profit figure as a target.
More Stories You May Like
- Sotheby’s Faces A Challenge Over A $180 Million Van Gogh Days Before Its New York Sale, As Heirs Of Its Prior German Owners Say It May Have Been Sold Under Duress
- Star Wars Turns 50 With A Wraparound 87 Foot Dome Screening At Cosm In Inglewood Starting March 2027, The First Film In A Multiyear Disney Deal
- Simple Plan, Hoobastank And The Used Surprise Passengers With A Concert Mid Flight From Los Angeles To Orlando, Playing The Reason, I’m Just A Kid And The Taste Of Ink


Leave a Reply