Two resellers walked into an estate sale with a simple game and a silly prize. They would ignore every photo in the ad, go in blind, and see who could find the most valuable item. The prize was a donut.

It is the kind of contest that sounds easy until the lights go out. The channel is Florida Pickers, and Stacy, who dug through a pitch-dark garage, ended up with a pair of old Santas that were worth far more than the remote her partner found.
“We’re going to play a little game,” one of them said at the start. “We’re going to go in blind and we’re going to see who can find the most valuable item.” When it came to the prize, they were clear about it: “A donut.”
“I Don’t Like To Lose,” One Reseller Warned Before The Doors Even Opened
They agreed that technically both of them would get donuts, so everyone wins. It was still a competition, and one of them was happy to say who the competitive one was. “One of us is definitely more competitive than the other,” came the line, and the answer was “That would be me. I don’t like to lose.”
It was one of their favorite estate sale companies, so they expected it to be good. They signed off to the camera and promised to meet inside once the doors opened.
Inside, each of them took a different route and did what resellers do. They flipped things over, checked tags and pulled out their phones to look at what similar items have sold for.
A Brand New Remote Looked Like A Sure Thing At $8
Stacy’s partner came out swinging early. The find was a brand new Logitech Harmony universal remote, model 4676, for $8. A universal remote sounded like a safe pick. “The universal remotes are almost always really good,” came the explanation.
The shelves held violins priced at $100 each and a musical instrument at $65, and portable CD players that could go for a lot. Then came a steel-sealed vintage Scrabble game in a closet. At one point the thought was, “Now I’m starting to get excited.”
Comps on the remote had not been checked yet, though. Confidence was high anyway. “That’s definitely a score,” was the verdict.
Stacy Walked Into A Dark Garage With Only Her Phone Light
Stacy had a theory. This estate sale company tends to put its holiday decorations in the garage, so she went to look for Christmas items. When she got there, the lights were out.
“The lights were completely out,” she said. “It was so dark. I couldn’t see anything. I had to use a flashlight on my phone.”
She found a bottle brush wreath with pine cones and little fake fruit, and she also found several bottle brush trees, including a tiny one and a pink one. She says she paid a dollar or two for the wreath and about a dollar each for the trees.
She also grabbed four cast iron reindeer. They were in rough shape, with one antler, a missing leg and half a foot gone, but she believes they are German and older and says they go for about $20 to $30 each.
“Anything With Felt, I Put In My Bag,” She Said, Digging Through A Dark Ornament Box
The real find came from two trays of ornaments. She says she used her phone light to dig through them, and she followed a simple rule. “I just saw anything I saw with felt I put in my bag cuz usually that’s like an older piece.”
She only saw what she had once she carried the pieces into a brighter room. There she says she realized they were something special.
She also picked up beaded sequin ornaments, a diorama angel ornament and a few little Japan-made figures. The ornaments were 50 cents each.
The Moment Of Truth Came, And A $35.73 Comp Made The Remote A $40 Item
It was time to present the best finds, and the remote went first. Nobody had checked comps, so they checked live. There was nothing sold on that model, but one brand new one was listed. A guess of $100 was in the air. The listing was $35.73.
“What? I thought it was going to be good,” came the reaction. “I’m shocked.” They rounded it up to $40. “Good try,” Stacy told him. “You got to beat 40.”
Then Stacy pulled out the Santas. “They don’t look like much,” she said. “They look pretty rough. But these are antique German Santa figurines.”
Antique German Santas Worth About $100 Each, Plus A Larger One With No Face
She explained how to tell they were old. “You can tell that they’re the antique Santas by the clay face, the felt outfit,” she said. She believes they are from the early 1900s, and she says she thinks they could be worth about $100. Asked whether that was for the pair or each, she said, “Maybe each.”
A third Santa was larger and in worse shape. The face is mostly gone, with no nose and no eyes, but it still has its little goose feather sprig. It is double or triple the size of the others.
When asked what comps she was seeing for similar pieces in decent condition, she said, “A couple hundred,” and then “two to three.”
The Rest Of The Haul Included A 1979 LEGO Set And A Scrabble Game From The 70s
Both of them found other treasures along the way. Stacy’s partner bought a LEGO universal building set, number 722, for $5. The box turned out to be from 1979.
The same shopper also took home a sealed Scrabble game that looks to be from the 70s for $3, which is worth about $25 to $30. Add a pair of Chinese food dog figurines for $20 that could bring $50 to $100 for the pair.
There were also sealed Dr. Scholl’s orthotic inserts for about $2, which cost 70 or 80 dollars in stores. At a second sale, Stacy found a green coin dot style piece for $3, and the last one sold for $50 shipped.
And yes, they went and got their donuts. They had an apple filled one and a raspberry filled one, and the apple one won the taste test. “I think we both won,” one of them said.
How To Use Comps Before You Pay For A Blind Estate Sale Find
This story has something for everyone who loves estate sales. Here are a few lessons you can use even if you never plan to resell anything.
- Check sold prices, not just asking prices. A listing is what someone hopes to get, and a sold price is what a buyer actually paid.
- Do not rule out a rough item. Stacy’s Santas looked rough, but age and material mattered more than the condition.
- Look for older materials like felt and clay. Stacy says those are often signs of an older piece.
If you are shopping a sale in the dark corner of a garage, carry a flashlight. Stacy’s phone light turned a box of ornaments into the best find of the day.
Most of all, keep it fun. As Stacy put it, a little competition makes the day more interesting, and there is always a donut at the end.
More Stories You May Like
- Dracula First Printing From 1897 Leads A First Ever Horror Literature Sale With A $30,000 To $50,000 Estimate, Alongside An Original Exorcist Advance Poster
- Woman Gets In Line At 5 AM For An Estate Sale, Sprints To Grab A 1960 Styrofoam Fireplace That Sold For $600, And Pays Only $150 Total
- Sellers Saw Just A Brass Box But This Antique Hunter Paid $60 For It Because It Is A Betel Nut Box Worth Far More


Leave a Reply