Imagine a store in Ontario, Canada, stocked with brand new Halloween decorations from the 1990s, never sold and never used. Now imagine that the store does not ship. That was the puzzle facing @shelbycelebrates, and a kind friend solved it.

The store is Party Warehouse Outlet in Toronto, and she describes it as a magical place filled with dead stock 1990s Halloween. Unless you know someone in Canada willing to pick up your order and mail it, she says, you are out of luck.
@shelbycelebrates
A Friend Named Emily Picked Up The Order And Shipped It To Missouri
When she posted about the store, a friend named Emily reached out and offered to help. Emily went to the store, picked up the order, took it to UPS and shipped the whole box to her home in Springfield, Missouri.
The price of the decorations was a bargain. The shipping was another story. She says she is not willing to admit what she paid to get the box to her house, because she had to cover international shipping and duties on top of the low prices.
When the box finally arrived, she called it feeling like Christmas morning. It was also, she says, the best birthday gift she could have asked for.
The $1.49 Skeleton In A Hot Pink Cape Was Her Number One Wish
The first item she pulls out is the one she wanted most, a vacuform skeleton in a hot pink cape. The price tag is still on it, and it reads $1.49. “This thing is pristine. It’s literally brand new,” she says.
She ordered two of them and wishes she had ordered more. Another vacuform piece shows a skeleton peeking out of a jack-o-lantern, and she says she is so pumped about it.
Then come the party supplies. She is a sucker for vintage party goods, and she found 1990s napkins and tablecloths, one made in Milwaukee. There were also several pumpkin lawn bags that she plans to use, though she loves the artwork too.
Beistle Die Cuts From 1973, 1990 And 1991 Never Taken Out Of The Package
She is a self described fan of Beistle, the maker of those classic paper die cut decorations. She ordered a Beistle die cut of a ghost and a jack-o-lantern in a cornfield, and she has several Beistle jointed skeletons already.
What she did not have were the night glow ones, because they are not made anymore. The glow in the dark die cuts are dead stock from 1990, which makes them 36 years old and never taken out of the package.
She also found a 14 inch tissue spider from 1993, a design she had been trying to track down for a long time. There was a Beistle ghost design from 1973, and a pair of tall jointed die cuts in the package from 1991.
One of those 1991 pieces is Patches the playful jointed scarecrow. She also scored a Beistle witch on a broom, with a face she loves and planets on the hat.
A 49 Inch Pumpkin Head Scarecrow Shows Up As A Surprise Replacement
She had asked for a 1970s Beistle pumpkin head scarecrow that was listed on the store’s website. It was not in stock, so the store sent a replacement instead.
The substitute is a jointed pumpkin head scarecrow by AmScan, and it is a whopping 49 inches tall. She says she will need to find a really big wall space to hang it.
$5 Shaking Ghosts, New In The Box From The 1990s
She saves what she calls the last big find for the end. The store listed shaking ghosts, new in the box, from the 1990s. She paid $5 for each, and of course she bought two.
In her words, if you had to sum up 1990s Halloween in one decoration, it would probably be this one. She had never owned a vintage one before.
Out came the batteries. One ghost works fully, which she finds amazing, since it was getting batteries for the first time in its roughly 40 year life. The other is not quite fully working, but she says she is ecstatic anyway.
Why Dead Stock Halloween Is Such A Treasure
Dead stock means new old stock, items that were made decades ago and never sold. For collectors, that is the dream. There is no sun fade, no torn corners and no missing parts, and the original packaging is still there.
Paper die cuts and thin plastic decorations were never meant to last, which is why mint ones are so hard to find. Most were used for a few Octobers and tossed.
If you want to chase the look without the hunt, she says a number of nostalgic designs are still being made today, and she keeps a list of them in her bio link.
The bigger lesson is about the people. She started with a store that would not ship and ended with a new friend named Emily, who did the legwork. That, she says, was the best part of her birthday.
If you have an old box of Halloween decorations in the attic, this is a good reminder to look at it with fresh eyes. Keep the originals in a dry spot, and hold onto any packaging, because collectors care about it.
More Stories You May Like
- Retired Decorator’s Attic Pokemon Binders Sell For £1.56 Million Including A Set Bought For £300 That Fetched £75,000
- 9 Ordinary Looking Items From The 1980s That Could Be Worth More Than You Think, And The Tiny Details That Make Collectors Pay Attention
- Mid 90s Goosebumps Board Game Let A Skull Dropped Down A Plastic Chute Decide Who Won, One Of The Creepiest Halloween Games Of The 90s Kids Forgot


Leave a Reply