Some of the best finds in the hobby come from the bottom shelf of a crowded booth. That is exactly where a collector who goes by 1ChrisChris spotted a big plastic bin of cards that had clearly been sitting for decades.

He paid $15 for it. It weighs about 10 pounds, and he figures it holds roughly 2,000 baseball cards from the mid 1990s. By his own guess, the whole thing looked untouched since the day it left a Walmart shelf.
A Quick Stop At A Favorite Booth Turned Into A Heavy Surprise
The story starts at a fall festival a few weeks before he filmed. He was there with his family, and whenever he is near Peggy’s Attic in Milan, Tennessee, he makes time for his favorite booth, run by a vendor called Out of Time.
He describes it as packed with 1980s and 1990s nostalgia, and he says the prices are fair. The family had only about 10 minutes in the whole store, but he says he never leaves without something in his hands.
Down on the very bottom shelf of that tiny, crammed booth he found a Jammers box filled with what collectors call junk wax, the flood of cards printed in huge numbers from the late 1980s through the 1990s. He also grabbed an Upper Deck Locker Room repack and a partial box of 2001 Fleer Futures, where packs ran $5 each.
He was already in the checkout line when his daughter called him back to the booth to look at something he had missed. That detour is how the 2001 box ended up in the pile too.
He Assumed It Had Been Sealed Since The $3.97 Walmart Days
The big tub is what really got him. He says it looked like something you would once have found on a Walmart shelf for around $3.97, and he assumes it was still sealed with its original tape from back then.
What sold him was a single glimpse of a Juan Gonzalez card off to the side. He says that was enough to convince him he had to take it home.
On camera he carefully sliced the tape, working around a sore left hand, and started digging in. His plan was simple: go through the cards one stack at a time and call out anything notable.
Hall Of Famers, Oddball Poses And Rockies Photos In Front Of Rock Walls
The first stretch was a parade of late 1990s Fleer, including a 1998 Fleer Sports Illustrated card of Ray Lankford, plus Andy Pettitte, Mike Piazza and Chan Ho Park. Partway through he pulled a Mark Grace card he says he did not own, and he declared himself satisfied right there.
“So already for $15 for this big huge tub of mid to late ’90s greatness I’m satisfied,” he says, and adds that anything else is “icing on the cake.”
Next came Stadium Club, including the old style that shows the rookie card on the back, then a run of 1993 Topps. Along the way he named Wade Boggs, Dennis Eckersley, Eddie Murray, Carlton Fisk and Paul Molitor. He notes that this is not a box of high dollar cards, but that pulling Hall of Famers out of a random $15 box is still a treat.
He had fun with the quirks too. A batch of early Rockies cards used odd backdrops in front of rock walls, which he joked looked like high school senior portraits.
The Cards He Is Saving For Autographs Through The Mail
A big part of why he buys boxes like this is autograph collecting by mail. He set aside Wade Boggs, Dennis Eckersley, Ron Gant, Paul Molitor and others he believes will sign when sent a card.
He says Eckersley is about $10 a card and Molitor is up to $20, and he points out that older players will not be around forever. If you are waiting to pay $5 to get a favorite player to sign something, he says, do it now.
Doubles do not go to waste either. He says he sometimes gives duplicates away to subscribers.
Shiny Fleer Glossies And Serial Numbered Oddities
He grew more excited when 1996 Fleer showed up in both the matte and the glossy versions. He says well graded glossies are sought after and that boxes of them could be had for about $50 a couple of years ago, but prices have since shot up.
A 1998 card with a gold label showing Griffey, McGwire, Sosa and Roger Maris from the home run chase caught his eye, and he says he is going to hunt for more for his personal collection. He also found a Galarraga insert from a Classic Confrontations set.
Then came the real head scratcher. He turned up late 1990s cards that were serial numbered, including a Raul Mondesi and a Bernard Gilkey, both numbered out of 9,799. He says the numbering seemed crazy for that era and invited viewers to explain the set.
Not every card was a winner. He mentions staining on a few, a crease in the Wade Boggs card, and some glossy cards that had gone a little sticky with age.
Why He Would Lose His Mind Over A Jeter Rookie
All the way through, he kept hoping for a long shot. Whenever he reached a stack of 1993 cards or the draft pick cards, he talked about the possibility of a Derek Jeter rookie turning up.
“I would absolutely lose my mind if right at the end of this break we pull a Jeter rookie,” he says. In the same breath he admits he can’t see it happening, then adds that stranger things have happened.
It did not happen. The last cards out were 1982 Topps in-action shots, including George Foster, and he wrapped the video there.
He is clear that the money was never the point. “It’s not always to me about how much a card’s worth as it is the memories and enjoyment you get from looking at some of these cards,” he says. He adds that if the same sealed tub were listed online, he is sure someone would put a $200 price tag on it, so $15 was perfect for him.
What To Know Before You Buy A Mystery Tub Of Cards
Cards from the late 1980s and 1990s were printed in enormous quantities, which is why most of them sell for very little today. The thrill is in the hunt, the Hall of Famers and the oddballs, not in a guaranteed payday.
If you want to try this yourself, a few habits help. Weigh the price against the pile, not against what a rare card in the box might fetch. Dig through the whole bin, because the best pieces are often buried. Condition matters a great deal, so set aside anything with creases, stains or sticky gloss and keep the clean cards in sleeves.
It also pays to check whether a player is known to sign through the mail before you spend on stamps, and to start with a few cards rather than a whole stack. And if you find a seller whose booth feels like your childhood, go back.
For a collector with a bad hand and a long upload, $15 bought him a full afternoon of memories. That is hard to beat.
More Stories You May Like
- Hayley Williams Brings Out Seu Jorge In Sao Paulo To Sing His Portuguese Bowie Cover Life On Mars, The Same Cover That Inspired A Verse On Her Song Zissou
- Def Leppard’s Vinyl Collection Volume 4 Includes An Unreleased Beatles Cover Of Revolution Recorded For A TV Ad That Never Aired
- Dimebag Darrell’s Famous Bathroom Guitar Goes On Display In Arlington, Texas Nearly 22 Years After His Death, In A City Exhibit That Also Holds His Amp


Leave a Reply