Collector Offers $200 For A Vintage Creature Glass At Chiller Theater Expo, Pays $220, Then Wishes He Had Grabbed A Second $50 Set Of Ratchet Candy Dispensers

·

·

Chiller Theater Expo is the kind of show where a collector can walk in for horror cookies and walk out with a Creature from the Black Lagoon. That is more or less what happened to the host of GenXJason on a weekend spent among vintage monster toys, lunch boxes and rock memorabilia.

A dimly lit room with shelves filled with collectible toys and figures.

The big buy of his day started with a dealer’s price, a counteroffer and a handshake at $220. The only regret came later, over a $50 set of candy dispensers.

The Dealer Asked $230, The Collector Offered $200, And They Met At $220

He went looking for a speed buggy lunchbox top and found a vintage Creature piece with the glass instead. The seller said it was clean, and it was his first time out at the show. “I would do 230,” the dealer told him.

The collector looked it over. There were no touch-ups, the figure looked solid, and the creature glass was one he had not seen in a long time, from a set the Hawkins company made in the early 1960s. “I’m thinking 200 bucks,” he said. They settled on $220.

It was the first big purchase of the day, and he rang it up with a grin. In his wrap-up he called it “an incredible buy for 220 bucks.”

No Cracks, Good Paint And The Original Cap On The Black Lagoon Prize

Back home on camera he described the piece as a vintage 1960s Creature from the Black Lagoon in terrific condition. He lifted it up to show there are no cracks and the paint is good, and it still has its original cap.

Collectors know why that matters. For vintage monster items, a missing cap or a hairline crack can pull the value down, so a complete piece with clean paint is the one people argue over. He says he was thrilled to add it to his personal collection.

A $50 Set Of Ratchet Candy Dispensers Looked Like A Steal, And He Took Only One

The next stop was a booth full of monster candy dispensers. The dealer’s werewolf looked, he joked, like an Amish man with a beard. The collector offered $50 for a set and the seller said yes.

The dealer explained that the sets are nearly identical, but the paint can vary, one more green, another more orange. “Collectors are particular,” he said, and the buyer agreed that he is one of those guys. He admitted he could stand there for 20 minutes just staring at the skull, the beard and the witch.

He bought the set he liked best for $50. By the time he got home he had changed his mind about leaving the others behind. “In hindsight, I probably should have grabbed the other ones,” he says, “because $50 for a set like this, it’s a really terrific price.” He then shrugged it off as good karma, a set left for somebody else.

A Cereal Box, An E.T. Bag And A Row Of Lunch Boxes With Serious Price Tags

Other purchases were smaller. He bought a monster cereal box for $10, taken with the colors and the artwork on the front and back. He remembers liking Count Chocula as a kid, though the cereal inside is long gone. An E.T. bag cost $15, and as he put it, “no E.T. left behind.”

Walking the aisles he also saw prices that make a collector whistle. A Mr. T item had a $350 tag. A Universal Monsters lunch box was $400 or $600 depending on the copy. A Beatles lunch box with its thermos was $550, a Partridge Family box with a metal thermos was $150, and a set of Groovy Ghoulies was $500 for the whole set, after retailing at $125 each. Another rare piece was a complete and unused color forms set priced at $100.

One dealer said he builds his table by saving stock over six months, putting aside horror toys in plastic tubs and then grabbing about 20 tubs for a show. Back at his shop, he said, the shelves look full even after the best pieces have gone to the expo.

Cookies, Ratt And A Famous Face In The Aisle

It was not all haggling. The collector crossed paths with actor Dan Roebuck, known for The Fugitive and Matlock, who was there with a friend known as Andy Dark Ride. The three went hunting for horror-themed cookies, including a Jason cookie, and the actor joked that people now recognize him from those dark ride videos.

The collector also picked up a Ratt koozie for his collection and spoke warmly about the band’s 1984 album Out of the Cellar. He says he was about 12 at the time and his friends played it after school while watching Headbangers Ball. The singer, he adds, still tours and has a solo record due in 2027.

How To Haggle At A Collector Show And Skip The Regret

You can borrow a few moves from the Creature deal. First, make a fair counteroffer, because the dealer started at $230 and ended at $220. Second, look closely at condition and original parts, like the cap. Third, when the price is great, trust yourself and buy the second one.

It is also smart to talk to the dealer. This one explained that collectors want specific paint colors, that his stock came from horror collections he buys, and that he does shows twice a season. Chatting costs nothing, and the story behind a piece is half the fun.

Which would you have taken home, the Black Lagoon creature or the candy dispensers? Tell us what you would have grabbed, and what you still think about years later.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *