If you grew up in the ’90s, you might have some cards or games tucked away that could be worth more than you think. Many items that seemed ordinary back then have gained value over time, catching the attention of collectors and fans of nostalgia alike.

Knowing which retro cards and games from the ’90s are now valuable can help you turn your old collection into cash. These items often hold sentimental value, but their worth today can be a surprising bonus for anyone willing to dig through their old stuff.

First Edition Pokémon Cards

If you’ve got first edition Pokémon cards, you might be sitting on something valuable. These cards, especially the Base Set Charizard, are highly sought after by collectors.

The key is in the details: look for the “First Edition” stamp on the card’s left side. Cards in near-perfect condition with this mark tend to fetch the best prices.

Grading your cards with services like PSA can also boost their value, sometimes dramatically. So, if you’ve kept yours safe, it’s worth checking them out!

Magic: The Gathering Black Lotus

If you have a Black Lotus card from the early ’90s, you might be sitting on something valuable. It’s one of the rarest and most sought-after cards in Magic: The Gathering.

This card was only printed in the Alpha, Beta, and Unlimited sets and is famous for giving a huge boost early in the game. Some mint copies have sold for millions.

Even worn-out versions can be worth thousands. So, if you find one, it’s definitely worth checking its condition and authenticity.

Wizards of the Coast Alpha Cards

If you’re into retro card collecting, Wizards of the Coast Alpha cards are a must-see. These were the very first Magic: The Gathering cards released in 1993, making them super rare.

You’ll notice their rounded edges and small print — details that set them apart from later sets. Because of their limited print run, Alpha cards often fetch high prices among collectors. If you find one in your collection, it might be worth checking out!

Rare Pokémon Holo Cards

If you’ve got some 90s Pokémon cards lying around, there might be a rare holo gem in your collection. Holo cards have that shiny background that makes them stand out, especially the Charizard from the original Base Set.

These cards aren’t just cool to look at; they can actually be worth quite a bit, depending on their condition and edition. Keep an eye out for first editions or cards graded by experts—they usually fetch higher prices.

Vintage Pokémon Base Set

If you have Pokémon Base Set cards from the 90s, you might be sitting on something valuable. Cards like Charizard, especially the Shadowless or 1st Edition versions, can fetch good prices if they’re in great condition.

Your card’s value goes way up when it’s graded by companies like PSA. Even other Base Set favorites like Blastoise and Venusaur have gained attention from collectors. So, check your collection—you might find some hidden gems.

Original Pokémon Theme Decks

If you grew up in the ’90s, you probably remember the excitement of opening a Pokémon theme deck. These pre-constructed decks gave you a ready-to-play set of cards, making it easy to jump into the game without building a deck from scratch.

Some original theme decks, especially sealed ones from the Base Set era, are now collectors’ items. Their value depends on condition and rarity, with certain editions like Brushfire standing out. You can still find them online, but prices have definitely gone up since the ’90s.