Erika Kirk is not waiting for the Super Bowl cameras to find her. As director and on-air face of Turning Point USA’s “All-American Halftime Show,” she has been dropping just enough hints to make her alternative broadcast sound like appointment viewing. The teasers are already colliding with a wave of criticism, turning what might have been a niche counterprogram into the latest flashpoint in the culture war around America’s biggest game.
Her pitch is simple but loaded: if fans are tired of the NFL’s official spectacle, she wants them to flip the channel, or at least hit record, and spend halftime with her instead. That promise, paired with her personal story and the politics wrapped around the project, is why both supporters and detractors are watching every new detail she lets slip.
The Bad Bunny backdrop and a brewing backlash
The entire concept of a rival halftime show only makes sense against the backdrop of this year’s Super Bowl booking. When organizers locked in Bad Bunny as the headliner, the choice landed like a provocation in parts of the religious right, which had already been grumbling about what they see as a steady drift toward explicit and politicized performances. That frustration hardened into talk of a boycott once it became clear that the Puerto Rican star would anchor the league’s biggest stage, with critics casting the decision as proof that the NFL is more interested in courting controversy than families.
Turning Point USA spotted an opening in that anger and moved quickly to frame its project as a direct answer to the official show. Conservative activists had already been circulating complaints about the Super Bowl lineup, pointing to Bad Bunny as shorthand for everything they think the league has gotten wrong. By positioning Erika Kirk’s broadcast as a clean, patriotic alternative, they are not just offering different entertainment, they are inviting viewers to make a statement with their remotes.
From AMFEST stage to “All-American” ringmaster
Erika Kirk did not appear out of nowhere to front this project. She has been a visible presence inside Turning Point USA’s orbit, including on the stage at AMFEST, the group’s annual AmericaFest convention that blends politics, celebrity and youth culture. That experience, where she has already juggled interviews with high profile guests and live crowd energy, is now being repurposed for a broadcast that aims to feel less like a corporate halftime package and more like a movement rally that happens to air during the game.
Her personal story is part of the pitch. After the assassination of her 31-year-old conservative activist husband, who co-founded Turning Point USA, Erika Kirk stepped into a more public role, and supporters now describe her as a widow turning grief into a mission. That narrative, amplified every time she walks on stage at a Turning Point USA event, gives the All-American Halftime Show a built-in emotional arc that standard NFL programming simply does not try to match.
What Erika Kirk is teasing about the show itself
On the content front, Kirk has been careful to keep some mystery while still feeding her base enough specifics to get them talking. Early previews have leaned hard into the idea of a “faith-filled” and “family-first” broadcast, with organizers promising that viewers will not have to worry about raunchy lyrics or surprise political stunts. At AmericaFest, Turning Point USA used a live crowd to hype what it called The All American Halftime Show, framing it as a powerful alternative that would feel more like a Sunday night worship concert than a Vegas residency.
Elsewhere, Turning Point USA has described the project as All American Halftime, a bold, faith-driven alternative that will spotlight themes of family and freedom rather than the usual pop spectacle. In promotional blasts, the group has promised a mix of patriotic music, testimonies and celebrity cameos that line up with its brand, while Kirk herself has hinted that the show is designed to be something parents can watch with kids without riding the mute button.
“Second halftime,” “new challenger,” and a culture war frame
Inside conservative circles, the language around the broadcast has gotten more dramatic with each new teaser. One viral post declared that America had just been handed a “second halftime” as the NFL gears up for Super Bowl 60, describing the All-American Halftime Show as a Bold New Challenger to the league’s official event and boasting that millions were already pledging to watch. Another promotion hyped a New Challenger to the Super Bowl, again using the phrase The All American Halftime Show to hammer home that this is not just a side stream, it is meant to compete.
That framing fits neatly into a broader narrative that has been building since Turning Point USA first floated a rival broadcast after the Bad Bunny announcement. When the group initially rolled out its plan for a competing option to the Super Bowl halftime show, it cast the move as a direct response to Bad Bunny and as a way to give Fans a Sup Bowl 60 halftime option that aligned with their values. Later, conservative commentary described the NFL booking and the Turning Point USA response as part of a larger clash over entertainment, with one analysis noting that, Moreover, just weeks ahead of the game, rumors of NFL fans being targeted by a parallel show helped turn Super Bowl LX into another front in America’s culture wars.
Boycott calls, critics, and the “don’t watch” moment
The hype has not come without blowback, and Erika Kirk has leaned into that tension. In one widely shared clip, she appeared as director of TPUSA’s All American Halftime Show and stunned viewers with a blunt command that went viral: “Don’t watch” the official halftime. That Don’t watch line crystallized what critics had been warning about, turning a programming choice into a loyalty test and drawing accusations that she was trying to police what Americans are allowed to enjoy on game day.
At the same time, supporters have celebrated what they see as a rare win against the entertainment establishment. One post crowed that They really did it, noting that a major network had greenlit Erika Kirk’s All American Halftime Show and predicting that TV execs in L.A. would be scrambling when everyone talks about it the next morning. Another message, shared among conservative fans, said They see the All American Halftime Show as a refreshing counterpoint to what they describe as an increasingly politicized tone in mainstream entertainment, even as it name-checked New York City NY, United States to underline how far the project’s reach could extend beyond its base.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:
Leave a Reply