Collector Who Wrote A Book Celebrating The 80s Sold Giant Size X-Men Number 7, Says He Could Get Rid Of 75% Of It And Be Happy, And Blames Three Dead VCRs

·

·

“I sold a copy of Giant Size X-Men number 7. And I don’t miss it at all.” That is how John, the creator behind That 80s Dude TV, opens his latest talk.

A stack of vintage comic books, matching a collector selling a key X-Men issue.

He adds that he could get rid of about 75% of his collection and be perfectly happy. Coming from a man who wrote a book about growing up Gen X and spent years celebrating the toys, comics, cards and games of the era, he admits that sounds a little strange.

The Author Of “Nostalgia Nation” Did Not Buy Back The Entire 80s

John wrote Nostalgia Nation, a book about the Gen X experience, and he has shared his collection on Instagram and other social media for years. He wants to clear something up first. He did not wake up during COVID, discover eBay and decide to buy back the entire 80s or 90s.

About 60% of his collection is original, he says. While he traveled for work, much of it sat in storage, and from around 2005 until roughly 2020 he barely bought anything. Comics, toys and baseball cards were all on the back burner until he started building his Instagram channel and began picking things up again.

“Am I Buying This Because I Really Want It Or Because I Need Something To Talk About Online?”

Comics came first, since they were among his first loves. He grew up reading them in the mid 80s and lived through the boom and bust of the 90s. He added some graded comics, a few graded cards he had always wanted, original Nintendo games and vintage toys, plus modern figures that paid homage to the past.

He enjoyed it. There is something satisfying about finally owning a toy or comic you wanted for years, and the packaging and artwork can take you right back. The trouble was what happened afterward.

He would get a figure, put it on the shelf, make a video about it, and that was pretty much the end. He wasn’t going back to it, and that began to weigh on him. So he asked himself the question that changed everything: “Am I buying this because I really want it or because I need something to talk about online?”

Prices Went Up, And So Did His Irritation

John says he was never buying everything in sight. If he found something cheap at a garage sale or swap meet, he might grab it, but more and more he looked at items and wondered if he needed them.

Prices did not help. He says that during and after COVID, it seemed everybody started collecting the same things. He would browse eBay, Mercari or OfferUp, see what sellers asked for a toy he remembered being cheap ten years earlier, and get irritated. Resellers can ask whatever they want, he says, “but that doesn’t mean I have to pay it.”

Three Dead VCRs Told Him The Hobby Had Gotten Ridiculous

VHS tapes are his best example. He loves the cover art and says a shelf of old slipcovers still makes him smile. But he has had three VCRs die on him. Three.

“You know your hobby’s getting a little ridiculous when you basically need another hobby just to keep the first one working.” He already owned most of those movies on DVD or digitally, so the tapes looked great but he wasn’t watching them. He says he has not missed buying VHS all that much, though he admits it is still in his blood.

Video games were another turning point. The Nintendo Switch got him excited about gaming again, and between older titles he can play digitally and newer games that capture the feel of his childhood, he was playing instead of collecting cartridges.

He pulled out an NES copy of Bionic Commando, one of his favorite games. He still loves the original hardware, he says, and understands why someone wants the complete game with the box and manual. But he asks why he should pay five to ten times as much for the cartridge when he can play it digitally. His rule now is one question: “Is this going to be the next game I actually play?” If not, he leaves it alone.

A Wife, Four Boys, And A Studio Full Of Things To Manage

Then there is the time. John recalls a day rearranging his studio that seemed to take forever, with shelves and boxes he had not touched in ages. He was spending his limited free time managing things he was supposed to be enjoying.

He has a career, a wife and four boys. Selling collectibles is not effortless either, since you have to photograph, list, package and ship everything. He says he does not want to turn his free time into another job.

It is also changing his videos. He will still make collection videos, but he does not want to buy something just to make a video about it. “I can talk about Thundercats without buying another Thundercats figure.”

His sons did not grow up with Teddy Ruxpin or the old Thundercats cartoons, and he says that is how it is supposed to work. They know how to load cassettes and CDs, play a record and pop in an NES game. Still, he would rather spend time making memories with them than hunt for another piece of the past every weekend.

The One Category He Still Collects, And The Comics He Let Go

One category he still genuinely enjoys is music. He listens to CDs, vinyl and sometimes cassettes, has upgraded some vintage audio equipment and has gotten into lossless digital audio. He shares it with one of his sons, who plays piano.

Those CDs and records get used and start conversations, he says. He is even considering buying back some of the CDs he once owned, especially from the 90s. They take up less room, and he knows he will listen to them, which he calls a very different purchase from a toy that sits untouched after a short Instagram reel.

He has sold a few things over the years, including early X-Men comics and vintage baseball cards. He says he occasionally thinks about a missing issue, but he does not sit around regretting the sales. He thought he might. He doesn’t.

What To Take From His Downsizing Rules

John is clear that he does not think collecting is bad. He still loves finding an old comic, seeing a beautifully designed toy or spotting something unexpected at a swap meet. “You do you,” he says of what anyone else can afford or enjoy.

His advice to his younger self is to pick one category you really enjoy and be truly selective. For him, it might have been music all along. If you are facing a crowded shelf of your own, his checklist is easy to borrow:

  • Ask whether you are buying because you want it or because you need something to share online.
  • Before buying a vintage game, ask if it is the next one you will actually play.
  • Count the hidden costs: photographing, listing, packing and shipping, plus the hours spent organizing.
  • Keep the things you use and that start conversations, such as records, and be honest about the rest.

John says he will keep special pieces and maybe hand some down, and he still plans to spend an occasional weekend hunting. He wrote Nostalgia Nation so the memories would live in one place, and he does not have to own everything he writes about. “I think I’ve got enough reminders already.”

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *