Thrifter Pays $1.50 For A Little Evening Bag, Hopes It Is Worth $2,000 Or $3,000, Then An Appraiser Says It Is Worth About $35,000

·

·

A woman walked into an appraisal event with a little jeweled evening bag she had picked up in a thrift store, and she walked out with a number that made her say, over and over, “That’s a lot of money.”

A black handbag with a leopard print strap resting on a green chair, like a thrift store evening bag find

She bought it around 2018 or 2019 for $1.50. She liked it and thought it was pretty, and that was the whole plan.

“You Are Kidding Me” Was The Reaction To What The Little Bag Really Is

The appraiser identified it as an art deco evening bag by Cartier, made in France in the 1920s or 1930s and signed Cartier inside. On the front sits a jeweled ornament in a design called a jardinetto, an Italian word meaning little garden.

The ornament is built in platinum. At its center is carved rock crystal, and around it the little garden blooms with rubies, emeralds and sapphires, many of them carved into leaves, flowers and berries. Old European cut diamonds, an early style with a softer, warmer sparkle, add light to the design.

The appraisal was filmed by the Heirloom House channel, and the moment of truth is the best part.

She Hoped For $2,000 Or $3,000, And The Appraiser Said About $35,000

Asked what she thought it was worth, the owner answered that she was hoping for maybe $2,000 or $3,000. The appraiser told her that, conservatively, in an auction situation it is worth about $35,000, and that this is fair market value.

Then came the second jolt. For insurance purposes, the appraiser said, the bag would easily be over $100,000.

That is a gap of more than 10 times what she hoped for, on an item that cost less than a cup of coffee. No wonder she kept saying it was wonderful.

The “Tutti Frutti” Style Came From A Trip To India

The colorful look is known as tutti frutti. It is closely associated with Cartier, and the story behind it is a good one.

The house of Cartier was founded in Paris in 1847 by the jeweler Louis Francois Cartier. In the early 20th century his three grandsons turned it into a global name. Louis ran the Paris house, Pierre opened the New York branch, and Jacques led the London branch.

The tutti frutti style grew out of Jacques Cartier’s travels in India, which began in 1911. There he met maharajas and studied the carved gemstones of the Mughal tradition, where craftsmen had long carved emeralds, rubies and sapphires into leaves and flowers.

He brought those stones back to Europe and set them in modern platinum designs, mixing colors that Western jewelers had rarely combined.

Platinum Let Jewelers Make Designs That Seemed To Float

Cartier was also a pioneer in platinum. The metal was strong enough to hold stones securely using very little material, which let jewelers create light, delicate pieces that seemed afloat.

Bags like this one belonged to a new social world. In the 1920s, women gained new freedom to go out to dinners, theaters and dance halls, and a jeweled bag became an essential accessory.

It had to be small enough to carry in the hand and bright enough to catch the light across a crowded room. The ornament on this bag is sewn onto the front, so its reverse and any additional marks stay hidden.

A Sand Bottle Was Next, And The Folk Art Experts Agreed On $25,000 To $30,000

The same appraisal event had more surprises. Another guest brought a sand art bottle by Andrew Clemens of McGregor, Iowa, made in the 1880s. The owner said she buys at estate sales and sometimes picks up boxes or a whole table of stuff, and she kept this one because it seemed special.

The bottle is a small glass apothecary bottle filled entirely with colored sand packed into detailed images, with no glue. Bands of geometric patterns run along the top and bottom, flowers fill one side, and a scene of sailing ships fills the back. Every line, petal and sail was formed from individual grains of sand.

Clemens gathered naturally colored sandstone from the bluffs along the Mississippi River near McGregor and, with his brother’s help, selected stones by color, ground them into powder and sorted the grains. Working with the bottle upside down, he placed the sand grain by grain with tools he made himself, including thin hickory sticks and a bent fish hook. A single bottle could take weeks.

After checking with colleagues at the folk art table, the appraiser said they were very comfortable with a retail range of $25,000 to $30,000. Clemens died in 1894 at just 37 years old, which makes each bottle even more precious.

A $40 Closet Find Turned Out To Be Archie Bunker’s Jacket

The third story starts at an estate sale in Malibu, California. A woman in line told the buyer it was the home of Carroll O’Connor, and upstairs the master bedroom closet was full of men’s clothes.

The buyer said they could not possibly be a father-in-law’s clothes. The answer was that the family’s mother never threw anything away, even though he had passed 15 years earlier. She bought one jacket for about $40.

It turned out to be a jacket worn by O’Connor as Archie Bunker on the television series All in the Family. It came directly from his estate, and photographs show him wearing it on the show. It was a store-bought piece rather than a custom costume, and a small American flag pin sits on the lapel.

In one photograph O’Connor wears it alongside Jean Stapleton, who played Edith. In another, from the 1972 episode with Sammy Davis Jr., the jacket hangs in the background. All in the Family premiered on CBS in 1971 and was created by Norman Lear, adapted from a British series, Till Death Do Us Part.

The appraiser’s estimate at auction was $10,000 to $15,000. The owner’s reply was the same one the bag’s owner gave: “You are kidding me.” She even said she would wear it walking the dog.

What The Thrift Store Bag Teaches Every Bargain Hunter

Three guests, three finds, one lesson. The bag cost $1.50, the jacket about $40, and the bottle came out of an estate sale haul, yet each was worth thousands.

The bag’s owner was not chasing a fortune. She bought it because she liked it and thought it was pretty, and that instinct is what saved it from being passed over.

If you thrift or go to estate sales, a few habits help. Turn pieces over and look inside for signatures, since the Cartier name was inside this bag. Look at the materials, because stones, platinum and hand work stand out from costume pieces. And when something feels special, keep it until an expert has had a look.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *