Writer Nobody Would Publish Mailed 200 Copies Of His Story As A Christmas Card, Then A Hollywood Producer Turned It Into A Film That Lost Money Before Television Made It A Classic

·

·

Every December, millions of families settle in to watch George Bailey discover what his life has meant to the people of Bedford Falls. It is hard to believe that the story behind It’s a Wonderful Life began with a writer who could not find anyone to publish it.

Christmas greeting card with festive decorations

Philip Van Doren Stern wrote a short story of roughly 4,000 words called “The Greatest Gift” in 1943. The idea came to him after a dream, but when he went looking for a publisher, the doors stayed closed.

No publisher would take it. So Stern did something wonderfully homespun that set the whole classic in motion.

The official Paramount Movies trailer for the film runs 76 seconds, and it still carries the warmth that made generations fall for the picture.

He Printed 200 Copies As A Christmas Card And Mailed Them To Friends

Stern printed 200 copies of the story as a 21-page Christmas card. He mailed them to friends and family, turning a rejected manuscript into a holiday gift.

It is the sort of move that sounds quaint now, but it worked in a way no one could have planned. One of those cards found its way to David Hempstead, a producer at RKO Pictures.

Hempstead passed the story to Cary Grant. RKO bought the rights, and both Grant and Gary Cooper were considered for the lead at that stage.

RKO Sold The Rights To Frank Capra’s Brand New Company

The project did not stay at RKO. In 1945 the studio sold the rights to Frank Capra’s new company, Liberty Films, and that is where the story found its director.

Capra was already one of Hollywood’s best-known storytellers, with films such as Mr. Smith Goes to Washington and It Happened One Night to his name. His new company was just starting out, and this was the picture it would be built around.

He raised $1.54 million to make it. Casting went to James Stewart as George Bailey and Donna Reed as Mary, and the little story in the Christmas card grew into a full Hollywood production.

The Cost Climbed To $3.18 Million, Making It Capra’s Most Expensive Film

The budget did not hold. The final cost rose to $3.18 million, which was more than double the money Capra had raised and made it the most expensive film of his career.

For a brand-new studio, that was a heavy weight to carry. Everything depended on how audiences would respond when the picture reached theaters.

It was released in December 1946, and the timing proved awkward. The film opened only weeks after The Best Years of Our Lives, another big, emotional picture about ordinary Americans.

The Film Was Reported To Have Lost Money

It’s a Wonderful Life was reported to have lost money on its first run. That was a painful result for a director who had put so much of himself into it, and for the young company that had backed him.

Capra later sold Liberty Films to Paramount. The studio that had been meant to give him independence ended up folded into one of the major companies, and the movie that was supposed to be a triumph sat in the record books as a disappointment.

If the story had ended there, the title would be a footnote today. A rejected short story and a box office letdown do not usually add up to a holiday tradition.

Television Turned A Flop Into A Christmas Classic

The real turn came decades later. In 1974 the film’s copyright was not renewed, which meant it entered the public domain.

That made it very cheap for television stations to broadcast, and many of them aired it every Christmas season. Viewers who had never seen it in a theater now met George Bailey in their living rooms, year after year, and the film found a new and much larger audience.

Repetition did what the box office could not. Families began to plan their evenings around the showing, and the film built the classic status it carries to this day.

Why The Story Behind The Story Still Matters

There is something deeply fitting about the film’s own history. It is a story about a man who believes his life has failed, only to discover that it has touched more people than he ever knew.

The movie itself followed a similar path. A writer was rejected, a studio lost money, and a director’s most expensive picture was written off as a disappointment. Yet the work lived on, passed from person to person, until it became something people felt they could not let December pass without.

For anyone with a creative project that seems to be going nowhere, the lesson is gentle but real. Stern did not wait for permission. He printed his story, mailed it to the people he cared about, and let it travel.

So the next time Bedford Falls appears on your screen and the bell rings at the end, remember the 200 little Christmas cards that started it all.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *