Sotheby’s Faces A Challenge Over A $180 Million Van Gogh Days Before Its New York Sale, As Heirs Of Its Prior German Owners Say It May Have Been Sold Under Duress

·

·

With a Van Gogh estimated at $180 million set to go on the block, a lawyer for the heirs of its former German owners has sent a warning to the auction house: prove this sale was fair, or do not hold it. The painting, “Chestnut Trees in Blossom,” is due to be sold Wednesday evening, November 18, 2026, in New York.

Paintings hanging on a white gallery wall

The heirs argue the picture may have been sold under duress during the Nazi era. The house says its research to date has not established that, and the two sides are talking.

A $180 Million Estimate That Beats Any Van Gogh Ever Sold

The painting is the centerpiece of “Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection” at Sotheby’s. The roughly $180 million estimate is the highest for any lot at this season’s major art auctions.

It is also higher than any price ever paid at auction for a Van Gogh. The current record is $117.2 million, set in November 2022 in New York for “Orchard with Cypresses” from the sale of Paul G. Allen’s collection.

The house has guaranteed the painting, which assures the seller a minimum price. That raises the stakes for everyone involved as the date approaches.

The Heirs’ Lawyer Says “No Auction May Take Place” Without Proof

The heirs, who live in the United States, are represented by Berlin lawyer Gunnar Schnabel. In a November 12 email to Marco Toracca, head of the house’s restitution department, he urged the house to prove beyond doubt that the painting was sold at market value in 1936.

He also asked for proof that the family “would have wanted to carry out the sale even without Nazi rule.” “Otherwise,” he wrote, “no auction may take place.”

Schnabel added that his client “is prepared to work toward a fair and just solution in the spirit of the 1998 Washington Principles.” Those are a non-binding set of 11 guidelines on how to approach artwork that was confiscated or looted by the Nazis.

The Auction House Says It Takes Provenance “Extremely Seriously”

The house responded with a statement. “Sotheby’s takes provenance and restitution matters extremely seriously and has undertaken extensive research into the ownership history of Chataigniers en fleurs,” it said.

The statement continued: “While our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress, we recognize the importance of engaging thoughtfully and constructively with the family and are committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution.”

The house says it will work with the family toward a solution. For now, the sale remains on the calendar.

A Village Street Painted Two Months Before Van Gogh’s Death

The oil on canvas measures 70 by 58 centimeters and was painted in May 1890 in Auvers-sur-Oise, near Paris. Van Gogh arrived there on May 20 after spending two years in the south of France, and he finished the picture within days.

He died on July 29, 1890, about two months later. The scene shows a village street with blooming chestnut trees, three women with parasols and a man in blue work clothes and a straw hat on the road, all in thick dots and dashes of paint.

According to the house’s announcement, the work had not been seen in public in more than 60 years. It is part of the collection assembled by Carlos Pedro Blaquier and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier of Buenos Aires, who began collecting Impressionist and modern art in the 1960s and acquired this painting in 1975.

Philip Hook, a former executive and author, described the collection in the sale announcement as “the stuff of legend: whispered about, kept from public view.”

From A Publisher’s Wall In 1909 To A Paris Sale In 1936

The painting entered the Fischer family collection in 1909, when Samuel Fischer, the prominent German publisher who founded S. Fischer Verlag, bought it from a Paris gallery. His authors included Thomas Mann, Hermann Hesse and Alfred Doblin.

After his death in 1934, his son-in-law Gottfried Bermann Fischer inherited the painting and the publishing house. As the Nazis took control, many of the house’s writers were banned, and Bermann Fischer left Berlin for Vienna about three months before the 1936 sale.

The family had left the painting with a dealer in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933. It was sold in 1936 to Henriette and Marcel Kapferer in Paris, then passed through several owners before the Blaquiers bought it in 1975. It was shown in Rotterdam in 1933 and in Bern in 1934.

The Heirs Point To The “Reich Flight Tax” And Company Losses

The Nazis restricted what Jews could take out of Germany, and the Fischer family had to pay the “Reich flight tax,” according to Schnabel’s research. The heirs say the Amsterdam sale was driven by financial losses their publishing company suffered under the Nazis.

After the war, Bermann Fischer regained ownership of the publishing house. He did not seek restitution for artworks sold during exile, because there was no legal basis then for recovering art sold in a country not under Nazi control, in this case the Netherlands in 1936.

What The Outcome Could Mean For Collectors And Families

The big question is whether the lot is withdrawn, delayed or sold with a settlement in place. Each outcome would send a different signal to collectors and to families pursuing claims.

It is the biggest-ticket painting of the fall auction season, and its sale could set a record for the artist. The claim turns on a long-running question about forced sales by families that fled Nazi persecution.

For anyone who buys, sells or simply admires art, the case is a reminder that a painting’s paper trail matters as much as its brushwork. Provenance research is now a central part of every major sale.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *