Georgia O’Keeffe Painting Bought For $3,800 In 1963 Went Into A Closet In Its Original Box After The Owner Worried A Guest Was Eyeing It Too Closely, And Christie’s Now Expects Up To $3 Million

·

·

Somewhere behind a wall of winter coats in an East Village apartment, a wooden box sat untouched for decades. Inside was a Georgia O’Keeffe landscape that its owner had bought for $3,800 in 1963 and then tucked out of sight, reportedly because a guest at a bridge game seemed to be admiring it a little too closely.

Watercolor landscape of rolling hills and distant mesas in earth tones

Now that painting, “Near Abiquiu, New Mexico I” from 1930, is heading to the auction block in New York. Christie’s will sell it on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, in its 20th Century Evening Sale, with an estimate the auction house puts in the region of $3 million.

It is the kind of attic-and-closet tale every collector dreams about, and this one comes with a cast worth knowing.

A $3,800 Graduation Present From The Artist’s Own Dealer

The painting was purchased on April 15, 1963, at the Downtown Gallery on East 51st Street in Manhattan, which was O’Keeffe’s dealer at the time. The price was $3,800. The buyer was the mother of a young woman who was finishing her master’s degree, and the painting became the daughter’s graduation gift.

That daughter kept it for more than sixty years. Her family has asked to stay anonymous, but they describe her in big words: “worldly,” “sophisticated,” “ultra intelligent,” “brave,” “strong” and “independent.”

She worked with the U.S. Foreign Service, traveled widely and spoke at least four languages. According to the family, she reportedly earned the highest score on the Civil Service Exam up to that time, and she was a world-ranked bridge master. She never married, guarded her privacy, and collected antiques and art.

The Bridge Game Moment That Sent A Masterpiece Into A Closet

For years she hung the O’Keeffe in her East Village home, living with it on the wall. That lasted until the mid-1980s. One account says that during a bridge game she noticed a guest “eyeing it a bit too closely.”

Whatever the exact reason, she took action. She packed the painting back into its original box and set it in the front closet, behind dozens of coats. There it stayed, and she apparently never made a fuss about it.

It is a very particular kind of collector’s instinct: own something extraordinary, tell almost no one, and keep it safe from curious eyes. The auction house describes the arrangement as a secret kept for decades.

“Oh, By The Way, There’s A Georgia O’Keeffe In The Closet”

The reveal came almost by accident. Years later her niece arrived to help get her aunt’s affairs in order, and the woman remarked casually, “Oh, by the way, there’s a Georgia O’Keeffe in the closet.”

The niece dug through the coats and found an old wooden box. Inside was the 10-by-24-inch painting, with O’Keeffe’s “OK” signature visible on the original backing board. The auction house says this happened earlier this year.

The niece, identified only as Betsy in one newspaper interview, was honest about her first thought. “I wondered, ‘Is there any way I can keep this?’ But once we started exploring what the value of the piece was, I realized that it’s worth more than my house.” She added, “For chuckles, I hung it up on the wall of my house for an afternoon, just to say I had a Georgia O’Keeffe in my house.”

Specialists Jumped To Their Feet And Ran To A Computer Screen

When the family contacted Christie’s, the reaction was instant. Tylee Abbott, senior specialist and head of American Art at the house, says the team gets a huge inbox of mostly unremarkable emails, but this one was “obviously exceptional.”

The team “immediately jumped to our feet and ran together and huddled around a computer screen,” then pulled books off the shelves to confirm the work in the literature. They called the family to say they would be right over.

Abbott called it “a wonderful painting, a remarkable story, and an extraordinary opportunity for collectors and the general public alike.” She also said rediscoveries are rare in the market for historic American artists, and that uncovering a seminal work is “a once-in-a-lifetime moment, and absolutely thrilling.”

A Painting Known Only From A 1931 Photograph

The reason experts were so stunned is simple. Before this discovery, the painting was known only through a photograph taken in 1931 and an entry in the appendix of O’Keeffe’s catalogue raisonne. It had not been seen publicly in at least three decades.

It is an early work, painted about a year after O’Keeffe’s first visit to New Mexico in 1929. It shows Lobo Peak, also called Lobo Mountain, near Taos, with rolling earth-toned hills and thick paint.

The painting is thought to be the first of a series of three. The second belongs to the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The third, from 1931, once belonged to David and Peggy Rockefeller and sold at Christie’s on May 9, 2018, for $8,412,500 against an estimate of $3 million to $5 million.

What O’Keeffe Said About The Mountain

O’Keeffe clearly loved that view. In a letter to her husband, Alfred Stieglitz, she wrote, “This is the Lobo Mountain… I want to paint this mountain, wanted to every year, but it is quite impossible.”

In another letter, to the critic Henry McBride, she described an adobe studio with a very large window, a green alfalfa field, sagebrush and a perfect mountain, saying it made her feel like flying.

O’Keeffe died in 1986 at age 98 and is often called the “Mother of American modernism.” That is part of why a lost canvas from her early New Mexico years draws such attention.

How To See It Before It Sells

You do not need a paddle to enjoy this one. The painting is on public view for free at 20 Rockefeller Center from November 7 to November 17, as part of Christie’s Marquee Week. The same week also showcases the collections of Clive Davis, Herbert Lust and Antonio Homem Sonnabend, among others.

If you are standing in front of your own closet right now, the lesson is a gentle one. Old boxes, original backing boards and signatures deserve a careful look before anything is tossed. Photograph the item, keep the paperwork, and ask a qualified specialist before you assume anything about value.

For one quiet woman and her coats, a guarded secret is about to become one of the most talked-about sales of the season. Part of the proceeds will go to an educational institution, and a $3,800 purchase from 1963 may now bring up to about $3 million.

More Stories You May Like



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *