Holiday playlists change every year, but a handful of Christmas records from the 1950s and 1960s still feel like the season’s default soundtrack. These albums mix lush orchestration, crooner warmth, and early rock and soul in a way that modern releases keep trying to copy, yet rarely replace.
Across ten standout LPs, from velvet-voiced ballads to Motown sparkle, the mid‑century approach to Christmas music still sets the mood for tree trimming, cocktail hours, and late‑night quiet once the lights are off and the needles start to fall.
1. Ella Fitzgerald’s Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas (1960)
Ella Fitzgerald’s Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas is the rare holiday record that feels both classy and genuinely fun. Critics regularly rank it among the top jazz Christmas sets, with swinging takes on standards that keep the brass bright and the tempos lively without losing warmth.
Later remasters highlighted how vibrant the mix is, with engineers at Sterling Sound sharpening every horn stab and brush of the snare. For listeners, that polish matters, because it turns background music into a full-room event, the kind of record that makes decorating or cocktail hour feel like a proper occasion.
2. Frank Sinatra’s A Jolly Christmas from Frank Sinatra (1957)
Frank Sinatra’s A Jolly Christmas from Frank Sinatra is the template for crooner holiday albums, pairing his relaxed phrasing with plush orchestral charts. Modern lists of essential seasonal listening still single out his smooth vocals for turning familiar carols into something closer to late-night torch songs.
Those arrangements matter for anyone trying to set a grown-up mood, because the strings and choir never overpower Sinatra, they frame him. The result is a record that works as softly playing ambience at dinner, yet also rewards close listening when the room finally quiets down.
3. Nat King Cole’s The Christmas Song (1960)
Nat King Cole’s The Christmas Song revolves around his definitive version of the title track, the one most people hear in their heads when they read “Chestnuts roasting on an open fire.” Contemporary rundowns of classic holiday records still highlight his velvety rendition as a mood-setter that practically radiates fireplace glow.
Beyond that single, Cole’s careful diction and jazz-informed phrasing keep the rest of the album from drifting into syrup. For families, it has become a sonic shorthand for tradition, the record you put on when you want the room to feel instantly calmer and more nostalgic.
4. Dean Martin’s The Dean Martin Christmas Album (1966)
The Dean Martin Christmas Album bottles mid-1960s lounge culture, all relaxed swing and half-smiling vocals. Curators of classic holiday music still point to his laid-back charm on seasonal standards as proof that Christmas music can feel a little tipsy without losing its heart.
That attitude has real stakes for how people use the record, because it turns background cheer into a kind of social lubricant. Put it on at a party and the room subtly shifts, leaning into clinking glasses, soft jokes, and the sense that nobody is in a rush to leave.
5. Andy Williams’ The Andy Williams Christmas Album (1963)
The Andy Williams Christmas Album is the sound of television-era family holidays, all choirs, bells, and that unmistakably bright tenor. Modern retrospectives still praise his wholesome delivery, which turns songs like “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year” into multi-generational sing-alongs.
For parents and grandparents, spinning this album is a way to bridge eras, connecting childhood memories of variety shows to kids raised on streaming playlists. It keeps the mood firmly PG, ideal for tree-trimming nights where the goal is cozy chaos rather than cocktail-bar cool.
6. Vince Guaraldi Trio’s A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965)
The Vince Guaraldi Trio’s A Charlie Brown Christmas quietly rewrote the rules for holiday soundtracks by putting jazz at the center of a kids’ animated special. Its piano-led themes are now cited among the jazz albums that shook the world, precisely because they smuggled sophisticated harmony into living rooms.
That crossover impact still shapes how families hear December, making brushed drums and walking bass feel as natural as sleigh bells. For anyone trying to balance nostalgia with something a little hipper, this album keeps the mood gentle while giving the ears more to chew on.
7. Phil Spector’s A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector (1963)
Phil Spector’s A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector turns carols into widescreen pop, stacking vocals and percussion into his trademark wall of sound. The track list pulls in the Ronettes, Crystals, Darlene Love, Bob, Soxx And The Blue Jeans and the rest of his stable, each blasting through arrangements built for AM radio dominance.
Analysts later noted how arrangers like Jack Nitzsche helped shape that overall sound, with Nitzsche, Phil Spector, Sonny Bono and Jack Nitzsche linked in discussions of pop orchestration. For modern listeners, the stakes are simple, this is the record that turns a quiet room into a full-on holiday blowout.
8. Ray Conniff Singers’ Christmas with the Ray Conniff Singers (1962)
Christmas with the Ray Conniff Singers helped define the easy-listening side of the season, all tight choral harmonies and gently swinging rhythm sections. Surveys of jazz-adjacent holiday records still praise Conniff’s harmonious choir style for lifting familiar melodies without weighing them down.
That approach makes the album a go-to for offices, shops, and big family gatherings, places where lyrics need to be clear and the mood upbeat but unobtrusive. It shows how carefully arranged voices can carry a room, proving that not every mood-setting record has to lean on star soloists.
9. The Beach Boys’ The Beach Boys’ Christmas Album (1964)
The Beach Boys’ Christmas Album brings West Coast sunshine to winter standards, folding sleigh bells into surf-rock rhythm and stacked harmonies. Modern rundowns of essential seasonal listening still spotlight how the group’s Beach Boys’ harmonies give traditional songs a fresh, youthful lift.
For younger listeners or anyone in warmer climates, that matters, the record proves Christmas music does not have to sound snowbound to feel authentic. It keeps the mood light and kinetic, ideal for daytime gatherings, road trips, or any setting where classic carols need a little extra kick.
10. Bing Crosby’s Merry Christmas (1957)
Bing Crosby’s Merry Christmas, a 1957 reissue of earlier sides, remains the bedrock of 1950s holiday listening. Guides to all-time seasonal staples still lean on his classic crooning, especially on “White Christmas,” as the sound that anchored mid-century celebrations.
Spinning it today is less about novelty and more about ritual, a way of plugging into the same sonic backdrop previous generations heard on radios and early LP players. That continuity is its real power, instantly setting a mood that feels timeless, slightly sentimental, and unmistakably December.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:
Leave a Reply