Over the years, I’ve watched plenty of little “junk drawer” treasures slip through my fingers—tiny things that didn’t seem to matter at the time. But lately, I keep hearing stories about folks cashing in on humble odds and ends they nearly tossed out with the trash. If you’re like me, you grew up in homes where kitchen counters, dresser drawers, and basement shelves collected more than a few forgotten gems. Before you do your next declutter, take a peek at these seven small items you might already own—some could be worth far more than you’d guess.
Vintage Pyrex Lids
If your mom was anything like mine, her collection of Pyrex bowls was the pride of the kitchen—from sunny daisy patterns to those sweet blue-and-white snowflakes. But here’s the kicker: it’s often the mismatched lids that collectors are desperate to find. My sister once uncovered a lonely turquoise Pyrex lid in a box of old Tupperware and sold it online for almost $80! Some rare patterns fetch upwards of $100 if they’re in good shape. So before you toss “extra” lids, double-check—one person’s spare is another’s missing piece.
First Edition Little Golden Books
Remember reading “The Poky Little Puppy” or “Tootle” to your kids (or maybe having them read to you)? Those slim Little Golden Books with the foil spines have a quiet cult following now, especially the earliest printings from the 1940s and 1950s. I found a stack in my parents’ basement and was amazed to see some first editions listed for $50 to $200, depending on condition and rarity. Even tattered copies can spark nostalgia—and bidding wars. Give those childhood classics a second look before donating or tossing them.
Old Costume Jewelry
My grandmother’s jewelry box was a treasure trove of glittering brooches, enamel pins, and clip-on earrings. Back then, nobody thought much of “costume jewelry”—it was just fun, affordable style. Now, designers like Trifari, Coro, and Weiss have become quite collectible. Unique pieces from the 1940s through the 1970s can sell for $50, $100, or even more if you hit the right audience. Even unmarked or “junk” jewelry can surprise you. Next time you sort through old accessories, set aside anything with weight, sparkle, or a fun design.
Unused Vintage Postage Stamps
When cleaning out my aunt’s desk, I found a stash of unused 3-cent stamps—she must have bought them in bulk for holiday cards. Turns out, stamp collectors love full sheets and rare misprints from the mid-20th century. Some are still only worth their face value, but certain stamps, especially commemorative issues or errors, might go for $50 or more per sheet. Rather than using them on your next birthday card, check online marketplaces or with a local collector. That roll of “old-fashioned” stamps could deliver a nice windfall.
Pez Dispensers from the 1960s and 1970s
If you ever stuffed Pez dispensers into stockings or Easter baskets, you might be holding onto a candy-coated jackpot. Early Pez characters—especially from the ‘60s and ‘70s—are surprisingly sought after, with some rare designs fetching $100 or more, even without the original packaging. My son rediscovered his Space Trooper Pez from childhood and was shocked to see what collectors were paying online. Don’t assume that just because it’s plastic, it’s worthless. Dig through those old toy bins before you toss anything quirky or colorful.
Tin Recipe Boxes with Handwritten Cards
There’s nothing like flipping through a tin box filled with handwritten recipes—some stained, others perfectly preserved, all full of family history. But beyond the sentimental value, those mid-century recipe tins have become collectibles in their own right. Patterns featuring fruit, florals, or polka dots are especially popular, and if yours still contains original handwritten cards, the combination can fetch $40 to $150. I’ve seen bidding wars for boxes with complete sets from the 1950s. Before you give up “Grandma’s old tin,” consider its potential—and the memories inside.
Advertising Keychains and Fobs
My dad had a drawer full of keychains—gas stations, banks, insurance agents—all tiny snapshots of Americana from the 1950s through the 1980s. What seemed like quirky swag then is now collectible ephemera. Certain brands, regional businesses, or unusual designs can bring $25 to $100 to the right collector. Some folks even hunt down complete sets or rare variants. If you stumble across a pile of old motel or dealership fobs, resist the urge to toss them—someone out there is hunting for that exact slice of nostalgia.
The next time you start spring cleaning or help a loved one downsize, take a moment to check those overlooked drawers and boxes. Small, ordinary things from decades past could be quietly gathering value—and bringing back memories along the way. Who knows? That unassuming trinket might just make your day, both in sentiment and in dollars.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:
Leave a Reply