Oprah Winfrey has spent decades turning her own body into a public case study, but her latest comments about obesity have pushed that conversation into a new kind of storm. After suggesting that obesity is a condition that “causes you to overeat” rather than the result of overeating itself, she has been hit with a wave of online criticism accusing her of being out of touch and even harmful. The clash lands at a moment when she is trying to reckon with her role in diet culture while also embracing new weight loss drugs, and the internet is not letting any of that slide.
The backlash is not just about one awkward phrase. It is about years of televised weigh‑ins, wagon‑of‑fat stunts, and brand deals colliding with a newer narrative that frames obesity as a chronic disease and weight loss injections as legitimate medical tools. The result is a messy, very public argument over who gets to define “health” and what responsibility a figure like Oprah carries when she speaks.
The remark that lit up social media
The latest flare‑up started when Oprah Winfrey framed obesity as something that “causes you to overeat,” flipping the usual logic that overeating leads to obesity. In a separate but related controversy, she has also been quoted making the controversial claim that “overeating doesn’t cause obesity,” a line that critics seized on as both scientifically shaky and rhetorically loaded, even as she tried to emphasize biology and brain chemistry over willpower in explaining weight gain. Those comments, reported as part of her evolving discussion of weight loss drugs, were quickly clipped, shared and stripped of nuance as they bounced around social feeds.
Online, the reaction was swift and unforgiving. One widely shared thread labeled her “delusional” for saying obesity “causes you to overeat,” calling the idea “completely ridiculous” and accusing her of rewriting basic cause and effect to justify medication use, a sentiment captured in coverage of how Social Media Users out. Another report highlighted how her line that “overeating doesn’t cause obesity” was framed as a “controversial claim” that seemed to erase lived experiences of people who have struggled with binge eating and food insecurity, with critics pointing to her own history of talking about portion control as they pushed back on the new framing from Oprah Winfrey.
“Thin people” and the weight loss drug divide
The uproar over her obesity comments did not happen in a vacuum. Oprah Winfrey has also been under fire for remarks about “thin people” who use weight loss drugs, comments she made after going on a medication herself following years of yo‑yo dieting. In one interview, she described how people who are naturally slim or who are on these drugs are not constantly thinking about food, suggesting that they only eat when they are hungry and do not experience the same mental “food noise,” a framing that critics said flattened the experiences of people who maintain lower weights through strict routines or disordered habits, as detailed in coverage of how Oprah Winfrey faced backlash.
Those remarks were amplified when another outlet noted that “Everyone is talking about this” as the media mogul’s comments about “thin people” and “food noise” sparked outrage among people who said they had worked for years through rigorous exercise and careful eating to maintain their size. Critics argued that by implying that thinness is simply the absence of obsessive thoughts about food, she erased the discipline and sometimes unhealthy behaviors that can sit behind smaller bodies, a tension captured in reporting that “Everyone” was watching Oprah Winfrey get dragged for ignoring those “rigorous efforts and healthy lifestyles.” The backlash has been sharpened by the fact that she has openly confirmed she is taking a weight loss drug after years of public dieting, a shift she discussed while acknowledging decades of yo‑yo patterns, as noted when Winfrey confirmed her new approach.
From “national sport” to diet culture regret
Part of what makes this backlash so charged is that Oprah Winfrey has been unusually candid about how brutal the public has been about her body. She has described how mocking her weight became a “national sport,” recalling years when tabloids and late‑night jokes treated every pound she gained or lost as open season. In one recent television special, she revisited that history and talked about how the scrutiny shaped her sense of self, with Oprah Winfrey explaining that the ridicule was relentless and deeply personal.
Another report, by culture reporter Charlotte Gallagher, noted how the Broadcaster and media mogul has tried to reclaim that narrative by producing an ABC TV special on weight loss medications and by donating her shares in a weight loss company to avoid conflicts of interest, a move described in detail when Charlotte Gallagher covered her decisions. She has also looked back on some of her most infamous stunts, including the time she wheeled out a wagon filled with fat to represent the weight she had lost, and admitted that she regrets how those moments fed into a culture that made it acceptable to “make fun of me for 25 years,” a reflection she shared when In December she revisited her role in diet culture.
Trying to pivot with obesity drugs, and hitting a nerve
In recent years, Oprah Winfrey has tried to reposition herself as a bridge between old‑school diet messaging and a newer medicalized view of obesity. She hosted an ABC special on the surge in obesity drug use, sitting down with medical experts to talk about medications that target what she and doctors described as “food noise” and brain pathways rather than just willpower, a conversation detailed in coverage of how Oprah Calls Out of criticism in that ABC Special on the Obesity Drug Trend. In that program, she also spoke about taking on the shame that had been projected onto her body for decades, arguing that people with obesity deserve compassion and access to treatment.
At the same time, she has been criticized for the way she talks about these drugs and the people who use them. One analysis described her remarks about weight loss as “truly annoying,” pointing out that she tried to denounce fat stigma while still praising weight loss as a kind of personal liberation, a tension that came through in coverage of Oprah Shares Some Truly Annoying Remarks About Weight Loss. Another piece, looking at her broader comments on weight loss, argued that her messaging can feel inauthentic, with fitness trainer Jillian Michaels saying in a segment of On Balance that Oprah’s statements about weight loss do not fully line up with her long history of promoting diets and products, a critique summarized in a clip titled “Oprah’s comments on weight loss are inauthentic.”
Owning her role in diet culture, while critics stay skeptical
Faced with this swirl of criticism, Oprah Winfrey has tried to publicly own the damage she believes she helped cause. While hosting a WeightWatchers live special called “Making the Shift” on a Thursday broadcast, she apologized for being a “major contributor” to diet culture and said she is “done with the shaming,” both of herself and others, a message she delivered while moderating a conversation about shifting away from punishment‑based dieting, as recounted in coverage that began with the word While describing that event. She has also spoken more broadly about how she wants people to stop shaming others for being overweight or for how they choose to lose, or not lose, weight, urging viewers to end the cycle of judgment that she says has haunted her for years, a plea she made when she called on audiences To stop shaming others.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:
Leave a Reply