The ’70s were a wild time for music. Disco was strutting its shiny stuff, rock was pushing boundaries, and singer-songwriters were sharing their innermost thoughts. But with all that fun came a slew of chart-toppers that still spark lively debates today. You know the ones I’m talking about—the songs that, despite their massive success, leave some listeners cringing. Let’s take a stroll down memory lane and revisit six of these notorious No. 1 hits that people can’t seem to stop complaining about.
1. “Afternoon Delight” by Starland Vocal Band
“Afternoon Delight” is one of those tunes you either love or can’t stand. Released in 1976, it was sweet, catchy, and, let’s be honest, a bit suggestive for its time. Critics argue that its bubblegum pop sound and lyrics alluding to a casual rendezvous make it cringe-worthy today. Yet, it still hits the nostalgia button for many who remember lazy afternoons and summer flings. Maybe it’s the overly cheerful vibe that has people rolling their eyes—like, can we just not with the cheesy lyrics, please?
2. “I’m Not in Love” by 10cc
This 1975 hit is a classic example of the ’70s art rock movement, but boy, did it divide opinions. The lush harmonies and dreamy production are undeniably impressive, yet some listeners find the lyrics to be overly dramatic. It’s like the song is saying, “I’m totally not into you, but let’s dwell on it for five minutes.” Some folks just can’t handle the emotional rollercoaster, and they’d rather stick to something a little less moody. Who knew a song could spark such passionate debates?
3. “Yummy Yummy Yummy (I Got Love in My Tummy)” by Ohio Express
If you’re looking for a song that’ll make you laugh (or cringe), look no further than “Yummy Yummy Yummy.” Released in 1968, it hit No. 1 in some places in the ’70s, and it’s as silly as it sounds. Critics have often pointed out how juvenile and nonsensical the lyrics are. It’s like a sugary candy-coated nightmare that refuses to leave your head. Sure, it’s catchy, but can we all agree that it’s hard to take seriously? Like, did they really think “tummy” was the best rhyme they could come up with?
4. “Love Will Keep Us Together” by Captain & Tennille
Ah, Captain & Tennille. Their 1975 hit “Love Will Keep Us Together” is an earworm that many either adore or find maddening. The upbeat melody makes you want to dance, but the lyrics can feel a bit too saccharine for some. You might hear someone say, “Do I really need to be reminded that love conquers all?” It’s like being trapped in a Hallmark card, and not everyone is here for it. Still, it’s hard not to smile when it comes on the radio—just don’t mention the cheesy sentiments around your more cynical friends!
5. “Disco Duck” by Rick Dees
Ah, the infamous “Disco Duck.” Released in 1976, this novelty song reached No. 1, and it’s a classic example of how the disco craze sometimes went too far. With its silly quacking and infectious beat, critics argue it’s one of the more ridiculous songs of the era. Some people just can’t handle the fact that a song about a dancing duck took the top spot over more serious contenders. It’s like a guilty pleasure you’re embarrassed to admit you enjoy, but hey, sometimes you just need to embrace the absurdity!
6. “Rock and Roll All Nite” by KISS

KISS is one of those bands that people either worship or roll their eyes at, and “Rock and Roll All Nite” is their anthem. Released in 1975, it’s a staple at parties and sporting events, but not everyone is on board. Some critics argue the song is more about spectacle than substance, with its repetitive chorus and over-the-top performance style. It’s kind of like if a party got too loud and obnoxious, and some folks just want to curl up in a quiet corner. But hey, if you’re into epic guitar riffs and glittery outfits, more power to you!
More from Vinyl and Velvet:


Leave a Reply