We’ve all been there: you hear a catchy tune, and suddenly you’re hit with a wave of nostalgia, wondering why you can’t remember who actually sang it. One-hit wonders have a funny way of sticking in your head while their artists fade into obscurity. But what’s even weirder is how often we misattribute these earworms to the wrong people. Grab your coffee, and let’s unravel the mystery of five one-hit wonders that everyone seems to get wrong.
“Tainted Love” – Soft Cell or Gloria Gaynor?
Okay, let’s kick things off with one of the biggest bangers of the ’80s. “Tainted Love” is practically the anthem of every ‘80s party, but folks often think it’s by the legendary Gloria Gaynor. Nope, it’s actually Soft Cell who gave us that synth-heavy classic. Sure, Gaynor’s “I Will Survive” is a timeless hit, but when it comes to “Tainted Love,” it’s all Soft Cell. You can see how the confusion happens—they both dominated the disco scene, and it’s easy to mix up those powerhouse performers.
“Come On Eileen” – Dexys Midnight Runners or Van Morrison?
Next up, we’ve got “Come On Eileen,” a track that’s basically the soundtrack to every wedding reception ever. Most people instantly associate this catchy tune with Van Morrison, but surprise! It’s actually the brainchild of Dexys Midnight Runners. This British band took the ’80s by storm with their energetic sound, but Van Morrison’s soulful style is just so iconic that it’s an easy mistake. You can’t blame people for getting mixed up when both have such memorable tunes!
“Ice Ice Baby” – Vanilla Ice or MC Hammer?

Ah, the infamous “Ice Ice Baby.” This song is so iconic that it practically has its own fan club. But here’s the kicker: many people mistakenly think it’s an MC Hammer track. I mean, they both rocked the ’90s hip-hop scene, but Vanilla Ice is the one who gave us that unforgettable bass line. It’s like confusing a hot fudge sundae with a banana split—both are delicious, but they’re definitely not the same! The misattribution likely stems from the fact that both artists were at the top of the charts, but let’s set the record straight: MC Hammer is all about those “Can’t Touch This” vibes.
“Bitter Sweet Symphony” – The Verve or The Rolling Stones?
Now, let’s chat about “Bitter Sweet Symphony.” This hauntingly beautiful track by The Verve is often thought to be a Rolling Stones song because of its prominent use of a Stones sample. While it’s true that The Verve had to navigate some serious legal waters over that sample, it’s the boys from The Verve who are responsible for the song’s ethereal vibe. People sometimes think of it as a classic rock staple, but it actually stands out in the ’90s Britpop era. It’s a classic case of “sample confusion,” and honestly, who can blame us? The Rolling Stones have been around forever, and their influence is undeniable.
“My Sharona” – The Knack or Elvis Costello?
Finally, we’ve got “My Sharona,” the quintessential power pop song that still gets stuck in people’s heads. Many folks mistakenly attribute this infectious jam to Elvis Costello, but it’s actually The Knack who created this masterpiece. The song is all about that irresistible crush, and its catchy guitar riff just won’t quit! It’s understandable that people mix it up—Costello was also a huge player in the late ’70s music scene. But when you hear that iconic opening riff, you’ve got to give credit where credit’s due: it’s The Knack who deserve the spotlight.
Wrapping It Up
So there you have it, five one-hit wonders that often get misattributed. It’s funny how music has a way of blurring lines and mixing memories. Maybe it’s the nostalgia that keeps us thinking of the wrong artists, or perhaps it’s just the joy of sharing a good tune with friends. Either way, the next time you hear one of these catchy tracks, you’ll know exactly who to credit. And who knows? You might just impress someone with your newfound knowledge—music trivia night, here you come!
More from Vinyl and Velvet:



Leave a Reply