If you love poking around thrift stores, the ’60s and ’70s are your sweet spot for finds that can turn a casual browse into serious money. From kitchenware to toys, plenty of once-everyday items now sell for hundreds, sometimes thousands, to collectors who crave that mid-century look and nostalgia.
Vintage Milk Glass Pieces
Vintage milk glass from the 1960s and 1970s looks simple at first glance, but certain patterns are quietly worth real cash. Collectors hunt for opaque white vases, cake stands, and compotes, especially pieces with intricate hobnail or grape motifs, and guides to collecting milk glass note that rare designs can bring hundreds at auction. Many beginners assume every white piece is valuable, yet condition, pattern name, and maker marks under the base are what actually move prices up.
To spot the good stuff in a crowded thrift aisle, look for heavier glass, crisp molded details, and sets that have all their pieces. A Pinterest value guide points out that Many collectors pay premiums for unusual forms like pedestal punch bowls or lidded hen dishes, so it pays to flip items over and check. If you are near a city with strong vintage culture, like the shops highlighted in a guide to the best thrift stores Boston locals love, you are even more likely to see higher-end milk glass rotate through the shelves.
Barbie Dolls from the Mod Era
Barbie dolls from the Mod Era, roughly the late 1960s into the early 1970s, are some of the most lucrative toys you can pull from a bin of dolls. A breakdown of valuable Barbies notes that The Barbies created between 1950 and 1970 can be worth anything from $100 to upwards of $20,000 depending on rarity, and that range absolutely covers Mod outfits and accessories. When you see rooted eyelashes, bendable legs, and wild printed mini dresses, you are in the right era.
Condition is everything, so you want original haircuts, intact face paint, and tagged clothing. Videos of collectors tracking down finds like Live Action Christie show how specific character names and outfits can send prices soaring. Lists of vintage dolls worth money consistently highlight Barbie as a cultural icon, which keeps demand strong among both toy collectors and fashion fans. If you spot a Mod Era Vintage Barbie with her shoes, stand, and booklet, you are looking at a doll that can easily out-earn your entire thrift haul.
Pyrex Kitchenware Sets
Colorful Pyrex from the 1960s and 1970s is the definition of “buy low, sell high” if you know what to grab. Guides to common thrift store finds point out that certain mixing bowl sets and casserole dishes often flip for $200 or more, especially in turquoise or pink patterns. Look for full nesting sets, refrigerator dishes with lids, and patterns like snowflake or daisy that scream mid-century kitchen.
Collectors care about both color and condition, so avoid pieces with heavy dishwasher fade or chips on the rims. Matching lids can be the difference between a casual resale and a serious collector price. Because Pyrex was used daily, complete sets are getting harder to find, which pushes values up. If you see a stack of vintage glass bowls hiding under a pile of plastic, it is worth taking the time to check the bases for pattern names and model numbers.
Chatty Cathy Talking Dolls
Chatty Cathy talking dolls from the early 1960s still have a devoted fan base, and that nostalgia translates into strong prices. A classic Vintage Chatty Cathy Commercial shows how Talking dolls were the latest vogue in the1960s and calls Mattel’s Chatty Cathy the most memorable of the talking dolls, which is exactly why collectors chase them now. In good condition, with the pull string working and the voice box still audible, they can reach up to $500.
When you spot one at a yard sale or during Thrift Shopping, check the back for the Mattel stamp and test the string gently. Even if the doll is no longer “chatty,” original clothing, clean vinyl, and rooted hair without haircuts still matter. Lists of vintage dolls worth way more than pretend money consistently include Chatty Cathy, which keeps demand steady among toy historians and people who grew up pulling that string.
Star Wars Action Figures
Early Star Wars action figures from the late 1970s, especially those made by Kenner, are some of the most bankable plastic you can find. Coverage of valuable childhood toys notes that mint figures like Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader from the original line can command prices over $1,000 when they are still on their cards. Even loose figures with original lightsabers and capes can bring in impressive amounts.
When you are digging through a bin of random toys, look for the tiny copyright stamps on the legs and the classic 3.75-inch scale. Accessories are crucial, so a blaster or lightsaber can be worth more than the figure itself. Because Star Wars fandom keeps expanding with every new generation, these early toys are not just nostalgic, they are part of a long-running franchise economy that shows no sign of slowing down.
Vintage Levi’s Denim Jackets
Vintage Levi’s denim jackets from the 1960s and 1970s are a staple flip for resellers who know their tags. Thrifting guides point out that classic trucker styles with original patches and natural wear patterns can sell for $300 or more, especially when they still have their paper or red tab labels intact. The earlier Type III silhouettes, with pointed flaps and shorter bodies, are particularly hot with fashion buyers.
To separate a valuable jacket from a basic one, check the care tags, stitching, and whether the red tab has a capital “E,” which signals an older piece. Distressing that happened naturally over decades is more desirable than modern factory rips. Because vintage denim is also a sustainability play, younger shoppers are willing to pay up for a jacket that looks good and keeps another garment out of the landfill, which only helps your resale margins.
Hot Wheels Redline Cars
Hot Wheels Redline cars from the late 1960s are tiny, but the money they bring in is not. Collectors focus on the signature red stripe on the tires and metallic Spectraflame paint, and sites like Redline Archeology explain that they pay strong prices for clean Hot Wheels Redline cars, race sets, store displays, prototype pieces, and accessories. Depending on rarity and condition, individual cars can fetch $100 to $500.
When you find a bag of Hot Wheels and Matchbox cars at a thrift store, it is worth digging for those early castings. Look for metal bases, bright candy colors, and that redline tire detail. Videos titled Incredible Redline Hot Wheels Find At The Thrift Store, with captions like Found a Valuable Hot Wheels Collection Lost in a Boston Basement, show how a single Part of a childhood stash can turn into a serious payday if you recognize what you are holding.
Mid-Century Board Games
Mid-century board games from the 1970s might look like cluttered cardboard boxes, but sealed or near-complete sets can be worth far more than their original prices. Articles about things hiding in grandma’s attic point out that unopened copies of classics like Risk or Clue can bring $150 or higher from collectors who want pristine examples. Even opened games with all the pieces and bright, unfaded boards can sell well.
When you see a stack of old games, open the lids and check for instruction booklets, full token sets, and intact inserts. Editions tied to specific years or artwork, like psychedelic 1970s covers, often have extra appeal. Because board games capture the look and language of their era, they are popular with designers and nostalgia buyers, not just hardcore gamers, which broadens your potential market.
Vintage Avon Bottles
Vintage Avon bottles from the 1960s and 1970s are another sleeper hit in the thrift aisle. Guides to common thrift store finds you can flip note that decorative perfume bottles shaped like cars, animals, or novelty figures often sell to collectors for $50 to $200. The key is finding unusual shapes, bright colors, and bottles with their original labels or boxes.
When you are scanning the glassware shelves, look for molded “Avon” marks on the base and check whether the bottle still has its cap and any remaining fragrance. Car-shaped decanters, owls, and holiday designs tend to move fastest online. Because these pieces are small and easy to ship, they are ideal if you are just starting to resell and want low-risk inventory that still has solid upside.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:
Leave a Reply