Ah, the one-hit wonder. It’s that delightful phenomenon where a song captures our hearts (and maybe our awkward dance moves) for just a fleeting moment. You hear it on the radio and think, “Man, this is a jam!” But then, you start to wonder: who the heck actually sings it? It’s a strange little world where songs can feel like they belong to someone else entirely, and that’s where misattribution comes in. Let’s chat about five one-hit wonders that you probably think belong to the wrong artists.
1. “Tainted Love” – Soft Cell or Gloria Jones?
First up, we’ve got “Tainted Love,” a song that’s been haunting dance floors since the early ’80s. Most people associate it with Soft Cell, and rightly so; their synth-heavy version is iconic. But here’s the kicker: the song was originally recorded by Gloria Jones back in 1965! She had a soulful take on it that never really got the attention it deserved until Soft Cell turned it into a synth-pop classic. It’s like finding out your favorite dish has a secret ingredient you never knew about.
2. “Bitter Sweet Symphony” – The Verve or Andrew Oldham?
Now, let’s talk about “Bitter Sweet Symphony.” The sweeping strings and that moody vibe? Totally The Verve, right? Well, sort of. While they’re the ones who made it famous in the ’90s, the melody actually comes from an orchestral cover of a Rolling Stones song by Andrew Oldham. The Verve had a bit of a legal tussle over the sample, which is a classic case of “who owns what?” But hey, it just goes to show that sometimes, inspiration can lead to some pretty sweet hits… and some pretty bitter lawsuits.
3. “I Want Candy” – Bow Wow Wow or The Strangeloves?

When you think of “I Want Candy,” you might picture the energetic Bow Wow Wow with their quirky ’80s vibe. But hold on a sec: this catchy tune was actually first recorded by The Strangeloves in 1965! Bow Wow Wow’s version is undeniably catchy, but it’s easy to forget that the song had a life before them. It’s like finding out your favorite cover song has an original version that’s just as fun—who knew music history could be such a delicious treat?
4. “Don’t You (Forget About Me)” – Simple Minds or Billy Idol?
Ah, “Don’t You (Forget About Me),” the anthem of every high school movie ever made. You might think it’s a Simple Minds original, and you’d be right in a way. But here’s a fun fact: Billy Idol was actually offered the song first! He turned it down, and Simple Minds swooped in to make it their own. Can you imagine how different the ’80s would’ve been if Billy had taken it? Maybe we’d be hearing “Dancing with Myself” in a whole new light!
5. “Take On Me” – A-ha or…?
Finally, let’s wrap things up with “Take On Me.” The iconic synth riff and that unforgettable high note? That’s all A-ha. But here’s the twist: many people think the song is just a one-hit wonder for them, but it actually had a life before it hit the charts. The song was initially released in 1984, but it didn’t catch on until they re-recorded it in 1985. So, while A-ha is undeniably the face of this track, it’s worth remembering that it had a bit of a rocky start before becoming a staple of the ’80s. Talk about a comeback!
So, there you have it—five one-hit wonders that often come with a side of misattribution. It’s wild how songs can weave their way through time, sometimes changing hands before they land in the spotlight. Next time you hear one of these tracks, you can impress your friends with a little music trivia. Who knows? You might even spark a lively debate over coffee! And remember, every song has a story—some just have a few more twists and turns than others.
More from Vinyl and Velvet:


Leave a Reply