3 Famous Musicians Who Couldn’t Stand Their Own Biggest Hit

Imagine pouring your heart and soul into a song, only to find out later that it’s the very one you can’t stand. It sounds bizarre, right? Yet, for some of the most celebrated musicians in history, this is a reality. Here’s a peek into the lives of three iconic artists who’ve had a love-hate relationship with their biggest hits. Grab your coffee; it’s story time!

1. Carly Rae Jepsen – “Call Me Maybe”

When Carly Rae Jepsen released “Call Me Maybe” in 2011, she probably had no idea it would turn into an anthem for the ages. With its catchy chorus and playful vibe, the song skyrocketed to the top of the charts worldwide. But here’s the kicker: Carly herself has admitted that she sometimes cringes when she hears it.

Why the mixed feelings? Well, Carly felt a bit pigeonholed by the song’s immense popularity. She’s a multifaceted artist who’s released a range of music from pop to indie, but “Call Me Maybe” became her defining moment. It’s like being known for that one embarrassing photo from high school — you love it, but you’d rather show off your other accomplishments, too.

2. Radiohead – “Creep”

Photo by Gie Knaeps

Ah, “Creep.” A song that defines a generation, right? Released in 1992, Radiohead’s breakout hit became an anthem for the awkward and misunderstood. But frontman Thom Yorke has been pretty vocal about his disdain for the track over the years. In fact, he’s even said that he wishes they’d never written it!

Yorke feels that the song oversimplifies the band’s artistry and has, at times, overshadowed their other works. It’s tough being a band that evolves, only to be constantly reminded of that one early hit. You can almost picture Thom rolling his eyes when someone yells “Creep” at a concert, wishing they’d shout out a deep cut instead. But hey, who wouldn’t love to have a song that makes people feel so deeply, even if it’s not their favorite?

3. Oasis – “Wonderwall”

Last but certainly not least, we’ve got Oasis and their mega-hit “Wonderwall.” Released in 1995, this song has become one of the most recognizable tunes of all time. But for Noel Gallagher, the song’s co-writer, it’s a bit of a double-edged sword. He’s admitted that he’s tired of playing it and has even referred to it as “the millstone around my neck.” Ouch!

What’s interesting is that while Gallagher might be over it, fans can’t get enough. “Wonderwall” has become a go-to for sing-alongs, campfire performances, and even the odd wedding. It’s that classic case of the artist wanting to move on while the world is still very much in love with their creation. You can almost hear the collective sigh of fans when they realize they might not hear their favorite song live anymore. But hey, that’s the price of fame!

Why Do Artists Feel This Way?

So, why do these musicians struggle with their biggest hits? Well, it’s a mix of a few things. First, there’s the desire for growth. Artists want to evolve, and sometimes their most famous songs can feel like an anchor keeping them tethered to a specific moment in time.

Then there’s the pressure. When a song blows up, it raises expectations, and that can be an overwhelming burden. The fear of being a one-hit wonder can haunt even the most successful artists. And let’s be real, no one wants to be known for just one song, right? It’s like being the person who only gets recognized for that one quirky thing they did in college.

Finding a Balance

Despite their complicated feelings about their biggest hits, these artists have learned to navigate the tricky waters of fame. They continue to create and evolve, proving that while they might not love their most popular songs, they respect the impact those songs have had on their lives and careers.

So, what can we learn from this? Maybe it’s okay to feel a little conflicted about our own “hits” in life — the things we’re known for. It’s natural to want to grow beyond our past while still recognizing how it shaped us. And who knows? Maybe the things we’re least fond of are also the things that resonate the most with others.

Vinyl and Velvet