If you grew up in the ’90s, you might still have some of your old toys tucked away. Over the years, some of these childhood favorites have gained value, turning from simple playthings into collectible treasures.

You might be surprised to learn which toys from your past are worth a fortune today and why they’ve become so valuable. Exploring these items can give you a new appreciation for your old collection — and maybe even some extra cash.

For more examples of valuable 90s toys, check out this list of 90s toys that are worth a fortune today.

Original Beanie Babies (first 5)

If you have the first five Original Beanie Babies, you might be holding onto some valuable toys. These early Beanie Babies are sought after by collectors because they were made in limited numbers.

Look for classic characters like Legs the Frog and Spot the Dog. Their value depends a lot on condition and tags. Keeping them in mint condition can make a big difference. Check out more details about Beanie Babies worth today here.

Pikachu Illustrator Pokémon Card

If you have a Pikachu Illustrator card, you’re holding one of the rarest Pokémon cards ever made. Only 39 exist, making it extremely valuable to collectors.

This card has sold for millions, and some sellers ask for even more. It’s often called the “Holy Grail” of Pokémon cards, so keep an eye on its market value if you own one.

Check out this Pikachu Illustrator card for more information.

Nintendo 64 Mario Kart 64

If you grew up in the ’90s, you probably remember racing your friends in Mario Kart 64. Now, the original Nintendo 64 release is surprisingly valuable.

A graded copy recently sold for over $21,000. This shows how much collectors want to own this classic game.

If you have a well-kept copy, you might want to check its value. You can learn more about its worth here.

Factory Sealed Disney VHS Tapes

If you still have Disney VHS tapes from the ’90s, keep them factory sealed. These unopened tapes can be worth a surprising amount today.

Titles like Song of the South and The Fox and the Hound are especially valuable. The key is that they haven’t been played or opened.

Collectors look for tapes in perfect condition, so your sealed copies could be a real find. Check out more on Disney VHS tapes worth a fortune today.

De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie

If you have the De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie, you’re holding a rare treasure. Released in 1999, this doll celebrates Barbie’s 40th birthday with a luxurious belt featuring 160 diamonds.

It’s one of the most valuable Barbies today, often worth around $85,000. This makes it a standout item for collectors and fans alike. For more details, check this guide.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Action Figures

If you still have your TMNT action figures from the ’90s, they might be worth more than you expect. Figures like Scratch, Shogun Shoate, and Hot Spot can fetch good prices, especially if they’re in great condition.

Some rare 1990s figures can sell for $50 to $100 or more with accessories. You can learn more about valuable TMNT collectibles here.

American Girl Dolls (90s editions)

If you have American Girl Dolls from the ’90s, they could be worth quite a bit today. Dolls like Molly and Kirsten Larson often sell for hundreds or even thousands, especially if they’re in their original outfits and good condition.

Keeping your doll and accessories intact can increase its value. You might want to check current prices for your specific doll online to see how much yours could be worth. For more details, visit this page on valuable American Girl Dolls from the ‘80s and ‘90s.

Furby Original Models

If you have an original Furby from 1998, it might be worth more than you think. Depending on its condition, your Furby could sell for anywhere between $200 and $1,000.

The rarer and better kept your Furby is, the higher the value. Keeping it in its original packaging can really boost the price. Check out more details on Furby values in 2025.

Polly Pocket Vintage Sets

If you grew up in the ’90s, you probably remember Polly Pocket. These tiny playsets were often sold for under $10 back then.

Today, many vintage Polly Pocket sets are worth much more, especially if they’re unopened or in great condition. Some rare sets from the mid-90s have become collector’s favorites, making your old toys a neat find. Check out more about these valuable sets here.

Vintage Barbie Dolls from the 90s

If you grew up in the 90s, you might have some Barbie dolls worth checking out. Many of these dolls, especially limited editions, have gained value over time.

You’ll find that holiday-themed Barbies or mass-produced dolls usually hold less value. But rare or special releases from that decade can be quite valuable today. For more details, see this list of valuable vintage Barbie dolls.